Skip to Main Content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York / Tri-State Area
  4. Manhattan
  5. Upper West Side

A Cafe New York - Permanently Closed

4.4
4.4
31 Reviews
$30 and under
French

A Cafe New York on Manhattan�s Upper West Side is a French Caribbean restaurant that serves up a fusion of fine French cooking and the spices and flavors of the Caribbean. The kitchen strives to maintain a sustainable dinner program that sources ingredients locally and seasonally. There is a BYOB policy and no corkage fee at A Caf� New York. A Caf� New York�s menu ranges from appetizers such as mousse trufee, baked D�Anjou pear and broiled Bourgogne escargot to a variety of main courses. They include the acorn squash bowl, rabbit sausages, the vegetarian seitan meatloaf and Gulf shrimp saut�.

Permanently Closed

This restaurant is permanently closed.

0 Photos

No photos have been uploaded for this restaurant yet.

Menu

Prix Fixe

$25. Choice of appetizer and main course from 6:00pm to 8:00pm

    Appetizers

    • Mousse truffée$10.00

      with black truffles & Port wine, side of béarnaise

      • Baked d'anjou pear$10.00

        with roquefort in a balsamic vinaigrette 10

        • Grilled Hass avocado$11.00

          vegetable terrine in a shiitake-sesame dressing

          • Broiled Bourgogne escargots$12.00

            with pastis in a cilantro-chili butter

            • Baked Scottish pheasant pâté$12.00

              truffle oil, cognac with a brie crust

              Main Courses

              • Wild mushroom ragout$16.00

                with tofu, Caribbean beans & alfalfa sprouts

                • Seitan 'meatloaf'$16.00

                  with butternut squash & apples in a mango gravy

                  • Acorn Squash Bowl$18.00

                    with chickpeas, soybeans & summer vegetables

                    • Free range smoked chicken breast$18.00

                      in a key lime & papaya purée

                      • Rabbit sausages$19.00

                        in a savory carrot-ginger & cashew purée

                        • Lamb Merguez sausages$19.00

                          with figs & dates in a coconut crème fraîche

                          • Gulf shrimp sauté$20.00

                            with parsley in a mild coconut milk curry over rice

                            • Roast duck leg confit$22.00

                              with jerk spices in a citrus jus reduction

                              For menu edits, please contact SinglePlatform at (866) 237-4564.

                              What 31 people are saying

                              Overall ratings and reviews

                              4.4
                              4.4 based on all time ratings
                              • 4.4Food
                              • 4.3Service
                              • 4.1Ambience
                              • 4.6Value

                              NoiseQuiet

                              95% of people would recommend it to a friend

                              Sort by

                              Filters

                              1. DP

                                DoPhi

                                New York Area

                                5 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                5 reviews

                                Dined on July 13, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                A Cafe is one of our favorite restaurants in NYC. The flavors are complex and delicious. We highly recommend the Duck Confit. Service is always friendly and attentive. It's a small place with a lot of charm, plus it's BYOB, so you can't beat that!

                              2. EA

                                EdAmbi

                                New York Area

                                11 reviews

                                vip
                                4.0

                                11 reviews

                                Dined on June 26, 2016

                                overall4food4service4ambience3

                                A pleasant surprise in an up and coming section of New York City. Well worth the trip for friendliness and an excellent combination of French and Caribbean food.

                              3. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                New York Area

                                1 review

                                5.0

                                1 review

                                Dined on May 24, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                What is there not to love about A Cafe? I mean, it's completely BYO, the menu is eclectic and delicious, the service is excellent and the prices are absolutely amazing. Myself and my colleagues from our wine store go here regularly and are never disappointed with anything and we love Al as well, he always does a great job knowing what we want and making sure we are always well taken care of.

                              4. D

                                Disappointing

                                New York Area

                                34 reviews

                                vip
                                4.0

                                34 reviews

                                Dined on May 20, 2016

                                overall4food4service4ambience4

                                This is a favorite (BYOB), although the menu does not change at all and is very limited, they do a reliable job on the duck, sausage and squash entrees.

                              5. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                Montana

                                1 review

                                vip
                                2.0

                                1 review

                                Dined on May 18, 2016

                                overall2food3service1ambience3

                                Nice atmosphere, but the service was painfully slow. There was only one other couple when we ate there (at 7:30 pm on a Wednesday), yet we waited over an hour for our food. We each had ordered only one entree. It was a mystery why it took so long given that the restaurant was so empty, and no explanation was offered. The food was good and creative, with a nice selection of vegetarian options. although the mushroom ragout was topped with an overwhelming amount of alfalfa sprouts. Perhaps the slow service was an anomaly, but I wouldn't try it again.

                              6. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                New York Area

                                7 reviews

                                4.0

                                7 reviews

                                Dined on May 18, 2016

                                overall4food4service3ambience3

                                My wife and I have been going to this UWS hidden gem for 6 years now. Amazing prix fixe special. This is a two man show (only the cook and utility man/owner host/waiter/busboy). Given the multiple responsibilities, service can be a bit slow at times - but the value / taste make up for this shortfall. BYOB is a great perk and owner always happy to chill beers or white wine for enjoyment throughout the meal.

                              7. P

                                Punskyta

                                New York Area

                                16 reviews

                                vip
                                1.0

                                16 reviews

                                Dined on May 13, 2016

                                overall1food2service1ambience3

                                We had to wait half an hour for appetizers and ONE FULL HOUR for our main course. We were a party of 2 and the place wasn't even at full capacity. But what could be expected when there are TWO people in total working the place? 1 cook/dishwasher + 1 host/waiter/busboy/receptionist. I hope they're getting paid tons of money, their jobs are insane. My food was just okay, my boyfriend hated his. Not coming back.

                              8. S

                                Sunflower

                                Seattle

                                30 reviews

                                4.0

                                30 reviews

                                Dined on May 8, 2016

                                overall4food3service3ambience4

                                The owner is lovely. The food is good but not every dish is exceptional! We really like the whole experience. The fact that we can take our own wine in is amazing!

                              9. MA

                                MargaretADT

                                New York Area

                                3 reviews

                                4.0

                                3 reviews

                                Dined on May 7, 2016

                                overall4food5service5ambience4

                                This is a small restaurant and there are not a lot of selections but what they have is varied so it would appeal to most diners and what they do, they do very well. Everything was fresh and flavorful and different from what you might find normally. Also, since it's a byob, your tab will be a bit lower than at a restaurant with a bard. They are very happy to open our bottles of wine and encouraged to sit and linger.

                              10. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                Mexico City

                                2 reviews

                                5.0

                                2 reviews

                                Dined on April 29, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                Excellent food, BYOB, and good service. The starter was so good that I thought the main would be not so good. But it was.

                              11. SK

                                StevenK

                                New York Area

                                13 reviews

                                vip
                                2.0

                                13 reviews

                                Dined on April 29, 2016

                                overall2food2service4ambience2

                                Oh my! So many good-great reviews. Why?? Food poor. Hot inside even at opening time Really inexcusable even w byob and moderate prices

                              12. r

                                rh24

                                New York Area

                                40 reviews

                                5.0

                                40 reviews

                                Dined on April 23, 2016

                                overall5food5service4ambience4

                                Enjoyed their prix fixe menu once again -- this time with friends who absolutely loved the place and the food. They would not stop thanking me for introducing them to this place. All of the following were excellent .. Appetizers: the pheasant pate with brie, the grilled avocado and the baked d'Anjou pear The mains: wild mushroom ragout, rabbit sausages and merguez sausages What is particularly noteworthy -- each dish is so different -- we had fun sampling from each other's orders and appreciating the unique flavors.

                              13. C

                                Chris

                                Sacramento

                                331 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                331 reviews

                                Dined on April 14, 2016

                                overall5food5service4ambience3

                                Had a wonderful meal at A Cafe NY. Owner greeted us at the door and service was friendly and helpful. The cuisine is French Caribbean, which led to an eclectic menu with intriguing favors and combinations of ingredients. Would definitely recommend the lamb sausages. The restaurant is "bring your own wine". Fortunately there is a nice wine shop across the street. There was no corkage fee.

                              14. T

                                Tuffcritic

                                New England

                                7 reviews

                                4.0

                                7 reviews

                                Dined on April 12, 2016

                                overall4food4service4ambience3

                                Nice, diverse menu of appetizers and main dishes including vegetarian, duck, seafood and others. Small cozy atmosphere, BYOB and if you forget, there's a liquor store next door. Little pricey for the neighborhood but just a little bit and the food is worth it.

                              15. D

                                Dijah

                                New York Area

                                18 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                18 reviews

                                Dined on March 26, 2016

                                overall5food5service4ambience4

                                Amazing meal! The food is some of the best I've had, and I'm a picky eater. The service is slow, but I didn't mind because we were well tended to. It's a great cozy spot for an intimate meal with friends/family.

                              16. c

                                carolyn

                                New York Area

                                22 reviews

                                vip
                                4.0

                                22 reviews

                                Dined on March 12, 2016

                                overall4food4service4ambience4

                                lovely, charming place. we enjoyed our meal. we particularly like the fact that this is a byob restaurant. this definitely makes it much more affordable. this is a two man show. one person cooks and the other waits. somehow they make it work. would definitely go back.

                              17. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                New York Area

                                5 reviews

                                5.0

                                5 reviews

                                Dined on February 16, 2016

                                overall5food4service5ambience5

                                Food and Service excellent. Very friendly and attentive service!! The small size and the nice atmosphere makes it perfect for a romantic dinner. They have a BYOB policy.

                              18. SH

                                StephenH

                                New York Area

                                162 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                162 reviews

                                Dined on February 7, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience4

                                I really enjoyed my dinner at A Cafe. I went with a group, we all got the Prix Fixe. Between that and the zero corkage charge for bringing your own wine, A Cafe is a bargain. The food was plentiful and tasty. The one man staff was friendly. I'll be going here again soon.

                              19. f

                                fisha

                                New York Area

                                11 reviews

                                5.0

                                11 reviews

                                Dined on February 5, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                A Cafe remains one of they best BYOB spots in NYC. It is the best value with an amazing price fix and a la carte menus.

                              20. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                New York Area

                                1 review

                                4.0

                                1 review

                                Dined on February 4, 2016

                                overall4food4service3ambience4

                                Tiny, classy restaurant, exotic food (small menu, which is good). However, we arrived at 8:05 (our reservation was for 8) and were disallowed the prix fixe dinner, which ended at 8. Since there was only one waiter, and he was slow, we considered the act petty, and we had dessert elsewhere.

                              21. J

                                Jeff

                                New York Area

                                43 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                43 reviews

                                Dined on January 30, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                I went to A Cafe when they first opened one block south of their current location in 2001. It was a tiny restaurant that served delicious meals. I had no idea it had found a new home nearby, and stumbled upon it recently. The dishes here are wonderfully creative, flavorful, and interesting. Each of the four in my group said, "This is extraordinary" in references to everything they ate. It was an experience none of us will forget. The food was exceptional. To our great surprise, it was matched by the service, an absolute gentleman who tended to us professionally without pressuring us to give up our table, despite the fact we were there enjoying ourselves for a few hours. We were stunned to discover that he was the only waiter on the floor. We found him a master of service, and a real pleasure to be around. I highly recommend A Cafe, though I think that was probably clear from the above. We'll all be back--and soon!

                              22. K

                                Katia

                                New York Area

                                2 reviews

                                5.0

                                2 reviews

                                Dined on January 26, 2016

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                Cafe A has a great ambience and excellent menu for vegetarians and meet eaters. The service is excellent and attentive. The desert is phenomenal.

                              23. d

                                doctorj

                                New York Area

                                10 reviews

                                vip
                                4.0

                                10 reviews

                                Dined on January 6, 2016

                                overall4food5service4ambience4

                                A Cafe is BYOB with no cork fee. They also have a $25 fixed price appetizer and main between 6-8pm (might be weekdays only). I had escargot + duck confit for $25! If you are on the upper west side you should try this place.

                              24. K

                                Kyas

                                New York Area

                                42 reviews

                                vip
                                2.0

                                42 reviews

                                Dined on December 11, 2015

                                overall2food2service1ambience2

                                The bus person was extremely rude. He acted as if he didn't want me there. The food was bland, and the chicken was extremely dry. I have never been to a restaurant where I felt so unwelcome.

                              25. M

                                Marisa

                                New York Area

                                11 reviews

                                5.0

                                11 reviews

                                Dined on December 10, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                Best French food. BYOB. Escargot is unforgettable. Hidden gem.

                              26. JB

                                JonBlack

                                New York Area

                                25 reviews

                                5.0

                                25 reviews

                                Dined on December 5, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience2

                                We arrived at the restaurant at about 6pm and we were the only diners there, within 15 minutes the restaurant was full. Menu isn't extensive but selections are made to order and very well done. It is BYOB but there is a liquor store across the street in case you forgot your favorite beverage. We were somewhat rushed because we were going to the theater, I will definitely return to enjoy another meal.

                              27. OT

                                OpenTable Diner

                                New York Area

                                4 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                4 reviews

                                Dined on November 25, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience4

                                Amazing food and great friendly service, we'll be back

                              28. C

                                Citygirl

                                New York Area

                                3 reviews

                                5.0

                                3 reviews

                                Dined on October 25, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                The food here is creative and special - I had the shrimp with coconut milk, my date had the duck, and our friends had chicken - everything is expertly prepared and beautifully displayed. You feel as though you are in a private home with servers! What a Fantastic Restaurant. The escargot is incredible and also the avocado appetizer --

                              29. RK

                                RobK

                                New York Area

                                29 reviews

                                5.0

                                29 reviews

                                Dined on October 21, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience3

                                We've been going to A for years, and it's always great. Some really unique dishes and combinations, great choices for vegetarians as well as meat eaters. Some dishes work out better than others, but even when unsuccessful, there is always energy and excitement of experimentation.

                              30. AW

                                AllisonW

                                Edmonton

                                7 reviews

                                5.0

                                7 reviews

                                Dined on October 2, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                This is worth the trip uptown. Small menu but found is excellent. And you can bring your own wine !

                              31. PM

                                PMK1

                                Raleigh

                                7 reviews

                                vip
                                5.0

                                7 reviews

                                Dined on August 8, 2015

                                overall5food5service5ambience5

                                Superb! Excellent choice.

                              FAQs

                              A Cafe New York - Permanently Closed is rated 4.4 stars by 31 OpenTable diners

                              Permanently Closed

                              This restaurant is permanently closed.

                              Become an Insider

                              Gain access to exclusive offers, best-of lists, local events & more (you can unsubscribe any time).

                              • Privacy Policy
                              • Terms of Use
                              • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
                              • Do Not Sell My Info (California)
                              Copyright © 2021 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
                              OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
                              Booking LogoPriceline LogoKAYAK LogoAgoda LogoRentalcars LogoOpenTable Logo