5 De Mayo
Served with rice and beans, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream and tortilla. Shrimp: this is a dish on your menu. Briefly describe it, e.g., Nachos, cheese, olives, jalapeno pepper, served with sour cream.
Cinco De Mayo Combo
Cheese quesadilla, chicken flauta, ground beef chimichanga, guacamole, sour cream and ranchero sauce
Great food with big portions at a great price.
Good was delicious!
Great experience. Brought my family & extra guests and the staff were attentive & attentive to our needs. It was busy that day & the warm staff was able to be accommodating to our party. Would definitely come back.
The food was delicious with generous portions. There were 4 of us, no complaints.
Overpriced is putting it mildly. Food was awful, service was worse. Overcharged us on our bill to top it off. Save your money and go somewhere else. Taco Bell would have been a better choice and this is coming from a foodie.
Food was average as were the drinks. Waited over an hour for our entrees. Definitely try to sit inside if you can.
Lets start with the margaritas.... They were nasty & it was 5|5. I was beyond disappointed!! Plus they were $15 NO BUENO.. I was not going to try the food. You should be ashamed to have that name on that day!! Never again... Dont do it. Find a Chilis!!!!
Very over Priced waiter new nothing on the menu recommend only the highest price food on menu and no desert on offer
$20 for a cassamigos club when regular restaurants are charging only $10/11
The food here is what saves them. The service is quite slow. It looks like they didn't have enough staff to take care of the amount of guest in house. Everything took quite a while but I was hanging with family so it wasn't too bad. The drinks here are terrible. Sorry not going to lie. We all had margaritas and they were awful. That is not good for a Mexican restaurant. The food portions are big and the prices are good. However, with all the amazing Mexican restaurants in NY and Long Island, I probably won't be back.
The food was AMAZING! I honestly can't say one bad thing. The service was great, the waiters were super accommodating and just ontop of everything. The music and vibe of the place was on point as well!
Had a wonderful time, food was delicious and the service was excellent!!!
It’s always a pleasure going to 5 De Mayo. The food is always delicious and the service is always great.
Last minute choice because something else fell through. Not a huge restaurant but amazing food, great accommodating staff and strong drinks. Will def be back.
Dont let the strip mall fool you the food was authentic and the drinks were good. The staff was attentive as well. Great little local find.
The whole staff was great and never had to ask for anything ,great food and very good drinks ,
The food was amazing! Very friendly and accommodating staff
Last minute decision to go to 5 de Mayo and we had a fabulous time. Food was delicious. Service was great. Great ambiance. Would definitely go back!
Great food and even better margaritas. The staff was friendly and very attentive
What a hidden little gem that we discovered! Had a wonderful Valentine’s Dinners here. Manager was welcoming and helpful the entire night and our server was exceptional. We will be back.
Local gem. Service was excellent. Food was authentic and tasty. Portions were generous.
Very authentic cuisine. Plentiful portions. Well worth the trip.
Food seasoned just right....not salty. The margaritas 🍹 are are great. Bartender and staff excellent!
The food is very authentic and the portions I’m very generous! Very well-balanced menu with many many options in all categories fish chicken meat and vegetarian This is not my first visit their repeat restaurant always consistently good on the atmosphere is very very pleasant. Not to mention they know how to make a great cocktail with real alcohol the margaritas are exceptional. Go hungry and you will be rewarded!
Food was below average. They didn’t bring everything I ordered. I was annoyed so I didn’t even bother to tell them. No Corona beer. What kind of Mexican restaurant doesn’t have Coronas.
Staff was friendly and quick service was provided. I wish they had at least gotten the order correctly.
Would I go back. No. Recommend. No.
My friend and I found this cute little place and the food was delicious and the service was great. The waitress was so nice and very attentive. I would most definitely come back here again.
Casual Atmosphere with high quality authentic cuisine. Will be back!
They had indoor seating, each table comfortably separated from the others. The food was delicious and plentiful, and the margaritas were excellent!
I was pleasantly surprised how good my meal was! I don't care for very spicy food. I had the Mayo combo, everything was well seasoned & tasty. Not spicy! Everything tasted freshly made. I'm looking forward to returning soon!
Food was great. Extremely understaffed. Wish I could give her a better rating but staffing was very very very slow.
Excellent food, warm, friendly service in a nice atmosphere! Will be back for sure...
Outstanding find. Found this restaurant through Open table while traveling. It had good reviews and looked like a value. We were not disappointed — lots of good food and at a low price. Very happy we found this local gem!
Food was fresh, flavorful and authentic. Steaks were juicy and cooked to the correct temperature, not overcooked. Continuous flow of crispy, tortilla chips and tasty desserts. Went in a group of 8 and 2 of our group cannot eat spicy foods and the kitchen was happy to oblige. Friendly attentive staff made the night extra enjoyable.
When we arrived we were surprised it was in a strip mall. Restaurant was casual and sparse in furnishings. Server was very accommodating, very sweet and very attentive. Food was excellent!!! Owner/chef Came out to check on us and make sure we were enjoying the food, which we definitely were! We are adding this our list. Looking forward to a return visit
The food was good and a decent value however the music was too loud as to hinder table conversation there also were a few linguistic issues that occurred in ordering however they were quickly resolved and the overall experience was good
The food was delicious and very good portions. Seems like they were understaffed when we were there. The overall ambiance could be better for the prices paid. There was a pile of supplies on the chairs in the corner near the entrance which was not a welcoming sight.
Our search is over!! We are looking for the best Mexican restaurant inLong Island. We found it. Great value the service was outstanding. So friendly and they didn't want you to leave. We are going back.
I dine there for Long Island restaurant week. The portions were plentiful and the food was good. My steak was cooked to perfection and was a nice size. What dine there again
I LOVE fajitas and this place has THE BEST! THE BEST JERRY, THE BEST!
I would give this place Zero stars if I could. Nachos were burnt, margarita was tasteless, watery & no alcohol. Black bean soup was watery & tasteless too. Chicken enchiladas had cold chicken inside. When I told waitress she rolled her eyes at me & told me they just made it & it was hot. I told her that the chicken was cold inside & beens & rice were cold too. She never offered to replace it so I asked for a manager and was told he was not there. Another waitress came & helped us get the bill and leave. Got dinner at Green Cactus & the experience there cost us $60 here with no dinner.
Yay! This place was so much fun and the food was delicious!! It was very lively, so if you want quiet, this is not the place, at least not on a Friday night. They had a Mariachi Band that was a total surprise. The waitstaff are friendly and attentive, and at the end of the meal, the chef came out and offered us some fresh watermelon as a dessert- such a nice touch.
The margaritas were ON POINT. Please go here and support this small business!!!
5 De Mayo does offer delivery in partnership with Postmates. 5 De Mayo also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 280-7795.
5 De Mayo is rated 4 stars by 158 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.