Consistently good seafood, nice atmosphere, and friendly staff.
The waiter was amazing, knew the menus like the back of his hand very knowledgeable and very friendly, also food was very great I had the 10 oz fillet mignon and my wife had the mahi-mahi we also indulges in the lobster tail it was amazing we were told they only do it three times a year and after eating it that’s just awful it was so delicious they should keep it on the menue in my opinion 5 star experience overall the price wasn’t all bad kind of high for my taste to be honest but well worth it
My wife and I celebrated Valentines at 42nd Street Oyster bar and the service and food was fantastic.
We waited way too long for our reservation. I know it was a holiday but we had a reservation and waited 25 mins after that to be seated. The food was great and service was pretty good. I just wish the hosts were better at their job.
My wife and I enjoy dining at the restaurant for the old time atmosphere, good seafood and generally good service. We ordered a shrimp cocktail to share, cheese potato, sweet potato, blackened grouper and salmon. Everything was delicious. The shrimp were fresh and crisp. The grouper and salmon arrived at our table piping hot. The blackened grouper was pretty spicy as I like it. The sweet potato was large and very good. The cheese potatoes OK. The hush puppies were delicious as always. The salads were fresh and crisp. Our server, Mara, was terrific. She was friendly, prompt and on the ball. We were seated in our preferred booth after a short wait on a busy Valentines Day evening. The restaurant does an excellent job planning for reservations. We are always seated promptly no matter how busy it is.
The service, food and atmosphere were great. We will definitely be back.
Shrimp and tomato risotto was excellent. Server was attentive. Made our Valentine's Day dinner a very pleasant experience.
Great service our table was ready as soon as we arrived. Wait staff got our order perfect. Attentive but not intrusive
All of the wait staff was very attentive. The food was great and the prices very reasonable.
First time at Raleigh location, have enjoyed at RDU before. Service was great, Food was very good, atmosphere nice too. If you are looking for seafood and a pleasant meal wrapped around it, this is the place. Great hush puppies, careful to leave room for your meal!!
The sampler oyster try was absolutely phenomenal. I haven't had oysters in awhile and that really hit the spot! We had a reservation at 7, arrived a few minutes late and were promptly seated. Our waitress was really sweet and helpful.
I hadn't been to 42nd Street for quite some time. It seems to have gone downhill. There were several mistakes in our order. Our server seemed distracted and did not bring requested items. She also took condiments away before we were finished with our meal. Also, the food was just "meh." For an establishment with such a reputation, and for the prices they charge, I expect a lot more.
The food was delicious as always! My son wanted crab legs for his birthday dinner and 42nd Street was the best choice! Kelly was an amazing server and was very attentive to our needs. And my son even got a free dessert for his birthday! All around a wonderful evening!
Delightful experience, as always!
Grilled fish was a bit over cooked for my palette; but everything else we ordered was DELICIOUS!
Always enjoy dinning at 42 nd street!!