1637 at York Harbor Inn
Excellent food and atmosphere as usual!!! Thank you!!
This restaurant is perfect in every way. Its setting is second to none. The atmosphere is cozy and historic, with a view that is modern-day-breathtaking. The menu selections are varied enough to accommodate all tastes. The local integrity of the ingredients is evident.
Service is excellent. The hostess makes rounds to ensure all patrons are happy. I am sure her job is easy, because the food is excellent. Drinks are just as yummy.
I live in York (moved here recently ) and always take guests here when they visit. I know I count count on a wow reaction.
Food was amazing. We stayed for the weekend and dined in their restaurants for the majority of the weekend. Food was great, located amazing. Had filet mignon, asparagus with mashed... delish. Steak cooked perfectly, salad was amazing. Had sandwich in the bar area for lunch -- would get again!
Our host (Greg) and waitstaff (Deb) service was fast and friendly. My wife said the Chicken Parmeasan she had was the best she ever had. I had Broil Haddock and loved it. We live nearby and will come here often.
The restaurant is beautiful and the views are gorgeous. The service was perfect. The food is expensive and not as good as we expected.
Setting is quite nice, the room has nice ambience and the service was good. But the food was disappointing. I might try lunch in the future......
Excellent pre-fixe choices for the early bird special. Service was great. Very enjoyable dinner.
Great deal and service. Whole meal was included to our stay at the inn as part of the winter special. From homemade bread and butter, soup, seafood pie and dessert to go - it was delicious!
Excellent food, service was personable. Took my significant other for birthday, did not disappoint. Watching the ocean crash against the coast was a treat as well. Easy to get to from Portsmouth area.
I enjoyed my dining experience on Saturday March 8, 2019 very much.
My date and I were seated in a quiet room which we really enjoyed.
The food was outstanding as always, and the service was excellent. i hold YHI to a high standard, and they always meet it.
Wonderful experience! Great food, great service! Fireplace was so cozy!
We both had the lobster carbonara which was amazingly good!
My food was excellent however my date’s food was heavily over salted
Have gone here many times and for the past few years for Valentine's Day. Haven't been disappointed yet and will probably continue to go back.
Food was absolutely delicious. Service staff at bar (both upstairs and downstairs) and the staff table side could hit have been better. Ultra-friendly and very helpful. I would recommend to everyone.
Amazing ambience, excellent food! Nicest people running the resort and restaurant.
Although we have been here several times I was a little disappointed this time with the table and with the hostesses unwillingness to move us to a different table. The table we were sat at was placed in a high traffic area where waitstaff continually need to go past to serve other tables. When I asked about moving to one of several open tables I was told sorry can’t do it yet many tables remained available for half an hour, The hostess came by to apologize awhile later once the appetizer came out and offered a glass of wine on the house I thanked her but then when the check came we were charged for the wine. It will be sometime before I return as I felt there really wasn’t an effort to accommodate us
1st time visit and we had a great time. Went on Valentine’s day and it was booked. Was nice, cozy and we were able to have a private conversation without over hearing others. Had a view of the water by sitting at a window seat. My filet mignon was delicious with béarnaise sauce. My wife enjoyed her chicken plate as well. Loved both desserts that we tried. Waitress and servers were pleasant and knowledgeable. May ask for a table near the fireplace next time:) Great overall experience!
Confusion when checking in but was taking care of when explained in detail. Couldn't understand why the Cont. breakfast was only until 9:30am. We missed brakfast and had to go elsewhere. No happy about that at all. All in All we would go back but not anytime soon.
Unfortunately our salad and hot appetizer came out simultaneously. The Caesar dressing was lacking in flavor and portion. The hostess did bring more but it tasted flat. I ordered mashed potatoes and received plain white rice. Thirdly our food was not very hot indicating it probably sat before being served. Our dinner seemed rushed despite it was not real crowded. My husband ordered the special” rack of lamb it was not juicy as expected. Pretty inn but food is just mediocre.
The 1637 at York Harbor Inn is a truly rare dining experience - first class food and service in a casual atmosphere. Colligan Filet, scallops, oysters - each better than the other! Cannot reccomend highly enoungh.
Enjoyable evening...friendly staff..delicious food
I ordered the Colligan Filet. It was absolutely fabulous. The combination of flavors and ingredients were outstanding. The wine selection was varied but not overwhelming. The staff was very attentive and the chef even came out to say hello and see if we were enjoying our meals. The bar with the fireplace was very cozy. I will definitely be making a return visit in the near future.
Great food outstanding service superb drinks by Beth what else can I say
We brought our friend to celebrate her birthday. I have been to The York Harbor Inn for brunch but never for dinner. We were all impressed and very pleased with our meals. Then we split a delicious ginger bread pudding. Our server recommended this to us and we were glad we followed her suggestion. Will make the trip again to dine at The York Harbor Inn!
Came to celebrate a birthday and placed that note in open table. However, there was no mention of it by wait staff during dinner.
The whole experience from dining to atmosphere was exceptional.
Perfection at Christmas time. Carolers singing as we dined!
We went here for my husband's birthday and they gave him a choice of dessert, which topped off the evening perfectly. The highlight of the evening though was the carolers who serenaded each section of diners -- simply beautiful! There was live music from the bar area so that we could relax before/after dinner and enjoy the cozy atmosphere. The food is always top shelf and served with graciousness and not a lot of fuss. Great place -- we will return!
Atmosphere was relaxing. Food was outstanding!
One of our favorite spots in York - we stay at the York Harbor Inn every year, and always look forward to our meal(s) at 1637 (and the Ship Cellar!). Even if you're not staying at the Inn, this is a MUST TRY restaurant anytime you're in the York area.
The filet with mushroom gravy ordered medium rare was cooked perfectly! My daughter has multiple food allergies and they took the care necessary to give her a great meal. LOVED IT!
We were staying at the Inn and decided to eat there as well. Our server was excellent. Very helpful when choosing a wine, our dinner and her dessert recommendation for the gingerbread, which was delicious.
We were seated immediately upon our arrival. Service was efficient yet friendly. Hostess was warm and personable. Members of our party just loved the food.
Very cute Inn and restaurant. The food was delicious and fresh!
Always a great time, great dinner, and great service.
Unfortunately this was a huge let down. My husband and I went for dinner on our first kid free weekend away in 4 years. We had dined here before and were very much looking forward to our evening. I found our waiter to not be very friendly however looked passed this. I ordered the seafood ravioli and my husband the stuffed haddock. I was surprised to see only 3 ravioli and tons of tomatoes with a scattering of seafood. The shrimp were inedible they were so over cooked as well were the scallops. When I asked the waiter to take it back he seemed annoyed and begrudgingly brought me a bowl of chowder. The chowder was mediocre at best. Edie stopped to check on dinner and when I explained what had happened the waiter very quickly cut myself and Edie off saying it was taken care of. Not once did we see a manager or was anyone besides Edie sympathetic. Very disappointing for a couple with a special needs son who chose here for the first night out in years.
Great Meal and I had the seasfood pie which was great plenty of Fresh seafood, We had a minor issue with scallops that were overcooked. This was immediately addressed, corrected and although our amazing waitstaff Jamie was apologetic the chef also came and apologized. It was a great experience. Tina was awesome and we returned again last night for a nice meal
Romantic cozy atmosphere. The food is always creatively presented and tastes delicious.
Food and service was top notch. Ian is an excellent server!