Tellers An American Chophouse
Steakhouse with great fishAt our table were two orders of Delmonico steak cooked to perfection and one order of Chilean sea bass. All items were very good.
The Chilean Sea Bass was extremely good. Highly recommend.6/10/2013 12:00:00 AMGood TimeFirst time with my wife. Food was great. My steak was a little over done I wanted medium rare however, it came out medium. My wife had the Wellington. They told was it will be rare but it did not look cooked at all in the middle but she sad it was good. Eight dollars for a Sam Adams seems a bit excessive. My biggest issue was they sat us at a table with roses on it (They were for someone else). I will be back.6/7/2013 12:00:00 AMa very nice experienceIt was a very nice night. Service was excellent food was top notch. The only negative was that the tables were very close together and the noise carried so much so that it made conversation a little difficult6/7/2013 12:00:00 AMWine Pairing on TuesdayThe menu selections with the pairings were outstanding, great California wines. The appetizer of lobster salad was not your typical fare, lumps of lobster with sliced yukon gold potato w/saffron paired with an outstanding white wine, "Overlook" by Justin Estates. Filet mignon cooked to perfection paired with a cab/merlot blend. Dessert was 7 layer chocolate cake paired with port wine - all from Justin Estates. Our waiter Willy was amazing as were all the members of the staff. We were celebrating a birthday and everyone who walked by wish my neice a Happy Birthday and they gave her a $25 gift card to return! It was her first time there and she loved it and I was very pleased to have been the one to bring her! Thank-you for a memorable meal!6/4/2013 12:00:00 AMNever DisappointedI have come here twice with my family, each to celebrate a special occasion and we have had nothing less than delicious, quality food each time. While it is definitely pricey, I highly recommend Teller's to anyone looking for spectacular food and a nice night out.5/29/2013 12:00:00 AMGreat SteakhouseTellers in it's previous life was a bank. The current décor is very modern and upbeat. Comfortable seating with pillows placed about for comfort.
Steaks, we had a Porterhouse for 2, were outrageous and more than sufficient for 2 people. The roasted Brussell Sprouts are a must have, sweet carmelized and yet a slight crunch. And of course you cannot beat the Oysters for freshness and farm a local farm.5/27/2013 12:00:00 AMNice DinnerGood food, great ambience, excellent service. The wait staff wasn't pushy, like many of the other notable steak houses we have frequented; here's looking at you Peter Luger's. The food was good, but I think the gems were the appetizers/desserts and not the steak. Diver Scallops were amazing, Caesar salad was okay, Duck fat fries were great, Cheesecake and Ice Cream really tasted as if they were made from scratch and not unfrozen from a box, Train wreck potatoes were what any self-respecting steak lover should order as a side. My lobster was overcooked and tough, but my 2 dinner guests and my wife loved their steak so I couldn't be happier.
Tremendous wait staff that was knowledgeable, professional, and there when you needed them.5/24/2013 12:00:00 AMExcellent LunchThe food and service here are always excellent but lunch adds another dimension: relaxed dining in a quiet, unhurried, atmosphere. Another great reason to eat at Tellers.5/23/2013 12:00:00 AMExcellent! Loved all the food!Excellent! Loved all the food! Awesone service...definitely recommend.5/18/2013 12:00:00 AMBirthday DinnerAtmosphere was fantastic. Nice and quiet - just the way I like it. Service needs to lighten up just a little. Don't like to feel like I'm being watched each bite. But very good nonetheless.5/14/2013 12:00:00 AMyummy steakThe porterhouse for 2 is among the best of the steak houses. Great waiter.
A beautiful dining experience.5/11/2013 12:00:00 AMDress codeMost were not dressed for the business casual , as advertised ,some looked like they were going to Macdonalds , service and food was done well my wife said the apple martini was the best she has ever had!5/7/2013 12:00:00 AMWhat's not to like at Tellers?Went to Tellers the first time last year - wish I had tried it much sooner! Just spent my 33rd wedding anniversary there during restaurant week and had a fantastic meal. They served three courses, we had the wine pairings (after a great cocktail and the terrific fries and breads), and everything was first-rate for a great fixed price. Serving was meticulous, the place is not real loud or dark, never feel rushed (courses come out timed very well - get to finish a course before the next comes, unlike lots of places, and the food was cooked to perfection and nice and hot). Tellers is my new favorite. And the music was pretty awesome! Not your everyday generic background noise. Overall, a great place to go.5/5/2013 12:00:00 AMFirst Time, Will Be Back!Awesome night: food was outstanding, seated right away, beautiful ambiance, servers were knowledgable, kind, friendly and helpful. Coincidentally was there during Restaurant Week and got an amazing deal: $50 per person, 3 course meal (several options available), wine with each course! Loved it-can't wait to go back!5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMRibeyeThe ribeye steak on the bone is outstanding! Scallop appetizer is very good. Whipped potatoes are excellent.5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMStill a GemPleasantly greeted. Opentable notes read. Service was good. Food was great. As we left we received a nice birthday gift card to return to the restaurant. During dessert we were also given a candle for the birth of our son. It's also the little things that matter.
Would have liked better seating than upstairs but I think they consider the upstairs to be special. All in all a very good experience.5/3/2013 12:00:00 AMAwesome As UsualMy wife and I went to the Tuesday night wine dinner where all of your courses are paired with a glass of wine. The vineyard featured that night was Bedell Cellars from Cutchogue Long Island. One of Long Islands best wine makers. My wife and I were engaged there and it was beautiful. Anyway the food here at Tellers is amazing. No doubt the best steakhouse on long island. Service was out of this world. Luis was our server and he was phenomenal. We've had Luis before and we will no doubt request him every time we go. It was a terrific night!4/30/2013 12:00:00 AMWe were pleasantly surprisedWe were pleasantly surprised to find it was restaurant week. There were 5 three course pris fixe meal specials for $40.
We (our party of four) tried three of them, all were delicious. My son had the ribeye and could not finish it. The grilled asparagus as well as the au gratin potatoes were to die for. The creme brulee' won our vote for the best dessert Reservations a must. We called on Friday for a prime Sunday 700pm.4/28/2013 12:00:00 AMTook friends to celebrateTook friends to celebrate their marriage. Great corner table, nice 3 hour long meal.
Food was very good, service was very good, prices are high. A lovely evening.4/27/2013 12:00:00 AMAll the food was top shelf.All the food was top shelf. Tellers ribeye is very special4/25/2013 12:00:00 AMWe went to celebrate our 30thWe went to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary, and Tellers was a great choice! Wonderful atmosphere, great service, and fabulous food. It would have been helpful to know in advance how large the side dishes were, but now we have lots of leftovers. The courses were spaced out nicely - no rushing at all. It was also nice to have wines by the glass - and they were really good! We'll be back!4/21/2013 12:00:00 AMDelicious night out for myDelicious night out for my wife and I at typical prices for a higher end steakhouse. The filet and skirt steaks that we ordered were delicious and the large portioned sides were equally good (we had the sauteed spinach and sweet potato brulee -- although the sweet potato brulee did not need as much of the marshmallow topping as they included -- it was sweet enough on its own). The staff was friendly and our waiter in particular was extremely helpful and personable. All in all, a great experience.4/20/2013 12:00:00 AMOur first time at TellersOur first time at Tellers and we loved it! Its going to be our new favorite dinner spot!4/13/2013 12:00:00 AMAlways enjoy meeting friendsAlways enjoy meeting friends at Teller's. Staff is friendly and service is impeccable. Expensive, but all Long Island steak houses are. Great salad and sides but steak and bread just OK.4/13/2013 12:00:00 AMI can't say enough about TellersI can't say enough about Tellers Restaurant. We went for my one Sons 25 Birthday and the food was excellent along with the service. The waiter overhear us talking about his birthday and had a special dessert brought to him. I realize it is expensive put you are getting top quality food4/6/2013 12:00:00 AMThe food and service wereThe food and service were great. When they found out it was my birthday, they sent over a piece of birthday cake. They also gave me a $25 gift certificate to any of their three restaurants. They really made my birthday special by doing this. I can't wait to get back there.4/6/2013 12:00:00 AMDecadent and delightful! ADecadent and delightful! A great night out with friends. This owner knows how to run
a restaurant...right down to the oversized ice cubes in a fine scotch on the rocks...
one of our favorite restaurants, hats off!4/6/2013 12:00:00 AMBest service I've ever hadBest service I've ever had -- food was obviously delicious also4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMGreat steak house with excellentGreat steak house with excellent food and service. Experienced wait staff .Steaks were well prepared and done as requested .4/4/2013 12:00:00 AMTeller's has always been aTeller's has always been a special restaurant on the south shore of Suffolk County. The food and drinks are moderately priced. The menu is based largely around steak, but there are a few seafood options. A good choice for tasty food in a unique setting.4/3/2013 12:00:00 AMDISAPPOINTEDTHE HAMBURGER & THE SALMON WERE NOT DONE AS REQUESTED. THE SALMON HAD TO BE SENT BACK. I ATE THE HAMBURGER, BECAUSE IT WAS MARGINALLY OK. MY EXPERIENCE AT TELLERS IS THAT THE CHEFS CAN NOT SEEM TO ACCEDE TO OUR "DONENESS" REQUESTS ACCURATELY!!!4/2/2013 12:00:00 AMAlthough prices appear highAlthough prices appear high they are on par with any of the other steak houses. Housed in an old bank the ambiance can't be beat. The wine list is extensive. NY strip steak and sweet potato brulee are fabulous. The chocolate cake=heaven. We have eaten here several times and have never had an issue.4/2/2013 12:00:00 AMBEST STEAKSEXCELLENT FOOD STEAKS RIHGT ON THE MARK. HAVE BEEN THERE SEVERAL TIMES ALWAYS GREAT.3/31/2013 12:00:00 AMFood and service were excellent.Food and service were excellent. Prices were high but worth it for a special occasion.3/31/2013 12:00:00 AMMore than just a steakhouse!It's been about 11 years since we've been to Teller's and the food is just as good as we remember, if not better. Although it's a steakhouse, there is something on the menu for everyone. I had many non-meat options and everything was impeccably presented as well as cooked to perfection. The extensive wine list was impressive and we very much enjoyed our selection. I highly recommend Teller's, as I think it's way more than a special occasion type of restaurant. My only issue was the acoustics in the restaurant and the proximity of the tables to one another on the main floor. It's not as intimate and quiet as I would have liked for our anniversary dinner, as we were forced to talk above the noise, but nevertheless we're going back.3/30/2013 12:00:00 AMLoved It!Excellent steaks, but the appetizers were fantastic as well. As good as the food was, the service may have been better. They heard it was our anniversary and by the time we sat at our table everyone of the staff knew it. Treated us like royalty.3/30/2013 12:00:00 AMAlways a wonderful experience.Always a wonderful experience. However, this time we felt ripped off by one of the specials. Be careful to ask the prices on the specials. We didn't and regretted it when the bill came.3/28/2013 12:00:00 AMWe have been to Tellers aWe have been to Tellers a number of times and always have a good time. Food is excellent as well as the service.3/28/2013 12:00:00 AMLoved it! Our waiter wasLoved it! Our waiter was very knowledgable and extremely attentive. Another great restaurant by Bolhson.3/26/2013 12:00:00 AMFood was very good. Veal TorteleniFood was very good. Veal Torteleni Carbonara was excellent appetizer. Steaks were up to Tellers reputation. Wine list is extensive and service was professional.3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMAlways enjoy Teller's. OneAlways enjoy Teller's. One of the best steakhouses on the Island. Wait staff is always top notch and steaks are prepared and presented well. They know what "rare" means...3/22/2013 12:00:00 AMGreatFood...Great ServiceTellers is now and has always been a superb dining establishment. From the time you enter through the food experience, it is top notch.3/21/2013 12:00:00 AMThe food was impeccable asThe food was impeccable as always but what really sets this place apart is the service. Steve was extremely knowledgeable and inviting. His professionalism made our experience a memorable one.3/21/2013 12:00:00 AMSteak & MoreAs always if you want Steak this is the place to go, great for any occasion.3/20/2013 12:00:00 AMA great find for a businessA great find for a business lunch meeting.
Wonderful service by Lisa & Billy.
Great lunch menu, plus they offer a pre fix menu.
It's a wonderful find in the Islip, Long Island Area.3/19/2013 12:00:00 AMExceptional meal...My husband and I chose to celebrate our 25th Wedding Anniversary here. My husband ordered from the Priced Fixed Menu (lobster bisque, strip steak, bread pudding), with wine pairings for $50-- the meal was excellent! When he didn't like the first wine pairing, Tellers gladly substituted another wine that he liked. I ordered the shrimp cocktail(the 3 shrimp are VERY large and expertly prepared), skirt steak (best I've ever had) and the Sweet Potato Brulee (which is so creamy and delicious, it could almost be served as a dessert) as a side. The service was attentive and unhurried. We've eaten here about 6 times, and we have never been disappointed.3/19/2013 12:00:00 AMeverything was excellent fromeverything was excellent from the time we arrived till the time we left.
food was prepared perfectly as ordered and was delicious.
wine list was extensive and the service was impeccable.3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMDinner was awesome. Food wasDinner was awesome. Food was delicious, waiter Steven was helpful with suggestions. He was at tentative but not overbearing. We were not rushed out of our seats. He made evening relaxing. We were seated earlier than our reservation time. The bar on the other hand didn't do as well. Took over 10 minutes to get a drink. It was so poor that waiters walking by serving bar area tables stopped twice and commented on the fact that we still had not been served. A manager then appeared behind the bar and asked if we needed something. She took the order and then walked away and we still didn't get served. Once we were served, the bartender then became very personable. Suggestion: hire more bartenders!3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMTwo very different vibes whetherTwo very different vibes whether you sit downstairs or upstairs. I was suspicious though of being sit upstairs. It was clear the staff were giving each other code words and so it felt like they decided we were fit for "upstairs". As it turned out it was probably ok because downstairs is way too noisy. Food good, choices limited. Some pasta dishes would be nice an maybe some vegetarian options.3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMthe food was excellent cookedthe food was excellent cooked perfect. service was very good. sat upstairs this time
quiet and nice. will definately be going back. do not hesitate to try this restaurant
you won,t be sorry.If you want good food...3/16/2013 12:00:00 AM