We have gone to Mitch & Toni's
We have gone to Mitch & Toni's many time and love it. We bring our kids who, while teens, have watch one to many Chef Ramsay shows & have become quite the critics :) With two kids we try to keep it reasonable, & in the past it has been easier. Pre fixe was off which makes it hard. My little Ramsays order off the main entrees & we felt pressure to '+ it' but did not. We need to budget below $200 which is hard. Appetizers and desserts are slightly overpriced. Great, but overpriced. Entrees are top $ but well worth it. Of our 4 dinners the only weak item was the potato augratin serve under a NY strip. All tried it, so it's not just the tastes of a 13 y/o, it was a 'brick'. I notice portion size from table to table varied too much.
4/4/2013 4:00:00 PM
We've eaten at Mitch & Toni's on several occasions and they 'wow' us every time. We started with a fun rounds of drinks including a blood-orange margarita and a jalapeño margarita. We kept it light for appetizers and had the felafel. What a treat...they were perfect! The entree selection offered a wide variety of choices pleasing to all palates. Our group had the pistachio crusted rack of lamb, grilled mahi mahi, the tuna special with three delicious dipping sauces and scrumptious BBQ beef short ribs. Even though we were kind of full, we couldn't resist dessert...the s'mores and dark chocolate semi-fredo were the perfect end to our wonderful meal. The staff are warm and friendly, and happy to accommodate you in any way they can.
4/5/2013 4:00:00 PM
great spot...nice trendy place...th
great spot...nice trendy place...the service was excellent...will absolutley go again.
4/7/2013 4:00:00 PM
My friend and I had a delicious
My friend and I had a delicious meal with wonderful service!
4/25/2013 4:00:00 PM
This was my first visit to
This was my first visit to this restaurant and we were all pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food.
The service was very good and the food well prepared. There was only one thing that slightly disappointed us. Our reservation was for a Saturday night and we were able to order from the prix fixe menu. However, the menu that was shown online was not the same as what was offered that evening. The waiter told us that this "early bird" menu shown online was only representative of the type of food served and did not represent the actual menu. Otherwise I would highly recommend Mitch & Toni's and I'm sure we will go back in the future.
5/3/2013 4:00:00 PM
absolutely love this restaurant.
absolutely love this restaurant. the food in innovative and delicious. they are always will ing to accomodate any special requests. i was there on a sat. evening and i went early to avoid the crowds and noise and just loved it.
5/3/2013 4:00:00 PM
Consistently Very Good
Mitch and Toni's continues to excel and get better. Although usually very good, the service was excellent and the food wonderful. A great neighborhood find with great food. ON Thursday's BYO bottle with no corkage. Life is good.
5/8/2013 4:00:00 PM
Great restaurant...innovative dishes with a high standard for quality. Reservation was honored & we sat upon arrival.
A must go to place on Long Island.
5/10/2013 4:00:00 PM
They've improved their menu and it's now replete with more eclectic and exciting dishes.
5/24/2013 4:00:00 PM
Had a gift card and hadnt had a chance to use it. When I saw the reservation slot on Open Table, I figured it was finally time. So glad we went there Saturday night. Great restaurant. Will definitely add this to our Saturday night rotation!
5/31/2013 4:00:00 PM
I have gone here several times with my family, and each time the food has been delicious and flavorful. Weel made with great ingredients. My most recent I had a wonderful experience with the co-owner. She went above and beyond to help my 2 year old to stop crying from her skinned Knees. She was very warm and personable. Which makes me want to go back cause we felt so welcome. And because of the Yummy food!
6/2/2013 12:00:00 AM
Delicious, tasty lunch - what
Delicious, tasty lunch - what a nice break in the middle of the day. Mitch & Tony's is a wonderful restaurant with tasty, appetizing choices.
6/5/2013 12:00:00 AM
very good food, music too loud
This was our second time to Mitch & Toni's, and the food was very good, though it is priced like a Manhattan restaurant. The wine list has several selections that are fairly priced. It was a Friday evening and there was a good musical combo playing during dinner. The problem was that they we so loud you couldn't hear across the table. Dinner music is great, this was more suitable for a bar.
6/7/2013 12:00:00 AM
I can always count on a good
I can always count on a good meal...done my way. They are very agreeable about substitution. My husband doesn't eat carbs, and they happily substituted stringbeans for his potato.
6/12/2013 12:00:00 AM
First time here... My husband had the prix fix dinner I ordered a la carte although we both had the same entree pan fried striped bas.. With couscous and zucchini.. I had a heirloom tomato salad with watermelon and we shared his dessert of 3 flavors of sorbet... We went early so that we could get over to our grandchildren's house to babysit so their parents could go out for dinner.... We had early reservations and we were alone until we were almost done.. About 7 ish and then the place started getting busy.. Wonderful staff and great food we shall return...
6/15/2013 12:00:00 AM
Taste the Adventure
They update their menu often to provide fresh, seasonal dishes. The food is always prepared perfectly. The service is friendly, attentive and precise, but you never feel like someone is hovering. I love this place and hope it stays forever.
6/20/2013 12:00:00 AM
Friendly & Flavorful
A nice atmosphere - welcoming staff that made everyone feel "at home"
Delightful service and delicious, unique offerings. All 5 of us enjoyed their meal.
We'll be back. Lots more we'd like to try..
7/2/2013 4:00:00 PM
since we always love this
since we always love this restaurant our only disappointment was when we arrived and the hostess (not toni) offered us the choice of 2 tables. one was in the corner next to the wall and the second was in the middle of the walkway. the restaurant was definitely not busy and i requested and different table for 2 and was accomodated. five minutes after we arrive other twos came in and were quickly seated at tables for 4 no questions asked. i certainly hope this was not because i used open table to make my reservation.
7/4/2013 12:00:00 AM
whether burger nite,brunch,bbq
whether burger nite,brunch,bbq or clambake,Mitch and Tonis always a winner.Truly a neighborhood gem.Great food and service consistent.We try and go weekly and love it here.
7/9/2013 12:00:00 AM
Definitely a great spot to go with friends or for a romantic dinner for two!
7/10/2013 12:00:00 AM
lots of nice midweek events.....wine pairing and tastings, clam bakes, burgers and beer....fun place, friendly staff, delicious food.
look forward to our next visit.
7/17/2013 12:00:00 AM
Fantastic food, as always, and great service. Toni, as hostess, is great at table hopping and conversation.
7/27/2013 12:00:00 AM
Luv this place
We've been here before but never had the burgers...OMG! by far the best burger ever! AND our tuna appetizer was great also! Still talking about what a great meal we had! Kudos.....
7/30/2013 12:00:00 AM
A nice night out
We waited 25 minutes despite having a reservation, but it was worth it. Everything was done to perfection. We got mussels for the table and shared a few salads (Roslyn and one of the others I can't remember). Oddly 3 of us ordered the tuna for our entrees-- incredible. The chicken (who orders chicken when you can make it at home?) was "the best I've ever had in my life," said my friend. Smores and some ice cream finished off a delicious evening. We'd go back again.
8/3/2013 12:00:00 AM
Burger night is a must!
Dining room is small and intimate with understated and elegant decor. The flat bread pizza and burgers are delicious and imaginative. The quality of the food is evident. Pair that with the fact that is obviously prepared with care and attention and you've got a winner. This is either a great 'date' night place or place to come with friends.
8/6/2013 12:00:00 AM
High prices, tiny portions
When paying $29 for a piece of fish, rice and vegetable, one should be able to find the fish on the plate. Usually for this price, I can take home another meal in leftovers in most restaurants. Anyway, my friend's hamburger was one of the best ever.
So order carefully and enjoy. Service was very good, but a Long Island neighborhood restaurant should not confuse themselves with Manhattan. I'd go back.
8/10/2013 12:00:00 AM
food, service and ambiance
food, service and ambiance excellent, would recommend to anybody looking for an exceptional restaurant
8/10/2013 12:00:00 AM
My family and I tried this
My family and I tried this place for the first time. We had passed it many times before and decided to finally try it. We were not disappointed. We love the polished yet intimate and warm feel of this place. The Long Island duck with mushroom barley and cherry compote was just a tad salty for me, but delectable nonetheless. The mussels were impeccably clean and lovely and the flat iron steak was delicious. Service was well-timed and friendly, wines were affordable. (On Mondays, select bottles are 30% off, and there's a prix-fixe menu too.) We would definitely would return to try more dishes and recommend it to our friends.
8/12/2013 12:00:00 AM
Need to update website
The food was excellent our only complaint was he fact that on the website the prix fix menu was totally different from what they were serving that day. It did not say that it changed daily and they had not changed it on the site yet. We did not care for what was on the the special that day
8/13/2013 12:00:00 AM
awesome, as usual
Once again we thoroughly enjoyed our meal!!! My husband wanted a particular type of hamburger which was NOT on the menu that nite. We asked if they could make it for him and sure enough they were pleased to accommodate him!! I ordered an appetizer for my entrée & they were happy to accommodate me as well as adding a serving of vegs to go along with it!
We LOVE this restaurant:))
8/17/2013 12:00:00 AM
This was our fifth or sixth
This was our fifth or sixth dinner at Mitch & Toni's. We really enjoy the food and the atmosphere.
We especially like our quiet table(#15) in the corner.
8/22/2013 12:00:00 AM
Amazing hamburger night!
We went for Hamburger night, great deal.... $10.00 for a burger and fries. Great food and great service!
8/27/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great neighborhood spot
Food was terrific! Server was friendly and very helpful in guiding a diner with food allergies to appropriate choices. The atmosphere was casual and neighborly yet the food sophisticated without being too fussy. Loved it!!
9/1/2013 12:00:00 AM
Have been to this restaurant several times.
Food has been great every time and service is attentive.
9/7/2013 12:00:00 AM
Will definitely be going back!
First time trying Mitch & Toni's and everything was fantastic. From the roasted beets and arugula salad, to the mahi mahi -- everything was cooked to perfection and flavorful. I would definitely go back and plan to in the near future. Also the service was amazing. Very friendly and attentive!
9/21/2013 12:00:00 AM
Always a special dinner
My family and I always look forward to a dinner at Mitch & Toni's. This visit was to celebrate a wedding anniversary. We sent on a Sunday which feature an additional family style menu. May work for some, but honestly, I rather see a prix fixe or more specials. The main menu has some great choices, but, as a returning customer it's getting hard to find something new. Menu or specials needs to be expanded to add more seasonal flavor. Still, all said, I won't hesitate to return.
9/22/2013 12:00:00 AM
We go to M & T about once a month. We find the food is always good. The service is impeccable and on a weeknight at about 6:30 it isn't crowded and you can really relax after a difficult day.
10/1/2013 12:00:00 AM
Excellent food, limited but
Excellent food, limited but quality menu. A bit overpriced.
10/19/2013 12:00:00 AM
Will be back
The food was excellent. My partner had the monk fish with bacon. It wss sweet and tastey. The side on smoked brussel sprouts were out of this world. I had the oumpkin ravioli as an appietizer, which was very good and the duck with pumpkin pudding. Both were excellent and prepared to perfection. I highly recommend this restuarant for anyone who truely appreciates fine cooking.
11/1/2013 5:00:00 PM
Restaurant Week visit
We have been to Mitch and Toni's before and enjoyed their food very much. So when we saw that they were participating in Restaurant Week, we made a reservation for Sunday night. Sadly for them, the restaurant was only partly filled. We ate off the special menu and were very pleased with what we ordered. I had sea bass for my entree with pumpkin ravioli as an appetizer. Both were delicious. The apple tart with ice cream that I ordered for dessert I did not enjoy as much. It looked very pretty. The tart was a lot of dough and very little apple. I did not eat it. The ice cream was delicious, though.
11/2/2013 5:00:00 PM
Really good food. No bargains on the wine list and the wine and water glasses should be switched. Overall good experience.
11/4/2013 4:00:00 PM
Nice food, seasonally fresh
A little confusion with our discount, but can't complain. Still a great deal and good food. A bit older crowd, well heeled Roslyn scene.
11/7/2013 4:00:00 PM
great food, way too noisy
food was delicious, creative presentations. The noise level was unbearable at dinner, Saturday night. I left with a sore throat from shouting.
Excellent martini, wonderful striped bass, fabulous dessert….However, for a restaurant without tablecloths, the prices were high. Not sure that I would go back. We went for restaurant week, and they did not honor the special menu as we arrived after 6PM. i couldn't find any limitations on the listing, so even though we decided to stay, it was not what we had planned. $150.00 for 2 people in a noisy bistro, 1 drink each, is excessive, I think. Leaving with a sore throat, not acceptable.
11/8/2013 4:00:00 PM
Honored reservation with a very good table on our arrival.
On Monday nights they have a special price menu with $9 per appetizer.
I ordered several
I wish I had known that the ribs had a lot of sauce o it.
They were too hot for my taste. I will order them again but request the sauce on the side.
11/17/2013 4:00:00 PM
My husband and I frequent this restaurant often. The food is always consistent. It is delicious. Every dish is flavorful and extremely tasty. Each dish is made to order, so you can make changes if you do not like a spice, or a side dish it is served with.
The waiters are always friendly and helpful, and the service is always good. This is one of my favorite restaurants, I recommend 100%. We have never been disappointed with a meal.
11/22/2013 4:00:00 PM
Always a very good meal
Mitch and Toni's is always consistently very good. The food is creative and delicious and the service is good.
11/25/2013 4:00:00 PM
Had not eaten Mitch's food since Bistro M, and was not disappointed. Lovely meal! Very good food , punctuated by vibrant flavor accents.
11/25/2013 4:00:00 PM
This is a neighborhood gem
Excellent food, clean and refined ambience with a friendly staff makes this an easy go-to place for any night of the week. Toni is the owner, makes a point of connecting with all her clients. Prices are surprisingly affordable given the number of specials offered during the week, while maintaining an upscale quality of service and food. Highly recommend.
11/26/2013 4:00:00 PM
Sunday night dinner
The food at Mitch and Toni's never disappoints. The prix-fixe is a great deal; delicious and big portions. Service was also excellent.
11/30/2013 4:00:00 PM
I ate at Mitch & Toni's on
I ate at Mitch & Toni's on a whim. I was 400 points away from 10,000 and wanted a restaurant with a 1,000 point reservation. Being paleo, I wanted a restaurant with gluten-free options. M & T's didn't disappoint. The cocktails (pear margarita) were strong and tasty. You got your money's worth. My friend and I shared the portobello mushroom with quinoa small bites dish that was outstanding as well as the vegan pasta. The latter you'd never guess was all vegetables. We also shared the strip steak (cooked superbly) and subbed the sweet potato and sauteed mushroom sides. The restaurant accommodated the subs with no questions or additional charges. They did charge for the shared entree but waived the charge when we questioned it.
12/4/2013 4:00:00 PM