Great Italian but a bit cramped.
Great Italian but a bit cramped. Service was friendly, courteous and attentive.
12/14/2012 12:00:00 AM
Great Spot in Gramercy Park
If a restaurant has been serving lunch and dinner since 1950, they must be doing something right. Classic Italian fare served in a comfortable dining room right off Gramercy Park. Moderately priced with something for everyone, from children to grandparents.
5/16/2013 4:00:00 PM
my secret place
paul & jimmys is a neighborhood gem. We eat there every chance we get. We have never had lunch there but did this time we did. It was wonderful. The prix-fix lunch was fabulous. The server was charming, friendly, competent & not intrusive. I highly recommend Paul and Jimmys. We love this place. We have gone there for years, usually post matinee this time pre theater. It has a wonderful ambiance. We love hearing Frank Sinatra playing all the time. This restaurant is a real gem. The owner is friendly and always welcoming. We never feel like strangers even tho we only get there a few times a year. It's always great food, great service and the perfect ambiance for good conversation. Looking for something great this is it
7/13/2013 12:00:00 AM
Girls Night Out
We enjoyed a delicious meal before theater. Our waiter was friendly, funny and accommodating. We will return.
7/18/2013 12:00:00 AM
Always a pleasure
Paul and Jimmy's is always good and sometimes it's spectacular. Staff are welcoming, accommodating, and friendly. The kitchen is willing to make reasonable substitutions when possible, and the menu ranges enough so most everyone can find something to eat. The food ranges from good to excellent; the portions are generous without being crazy. The noise level is tolerable (for those of us who like to talk with our companions over dinner). It is a neighborhood staple, and rightly so.
9/18/2013 12:00:00 AM
Family outing for grandma's birthday. It's definitely an old neighborhood spot; the crowd appeared on the older/local side. Good Italian food, reasonably priced (prixe fix dinner for $30) with a nice, relaxed atmosphere. Perfect for celebrating the birthday of someone looking for a quieter spot but still in a convenient location (not far from Union Square).
9/21/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great for Large Groups
We had a superb dinner for 25 people and had a need to complete the dinner within 2 hours. We arranged to be served family style so the food kept flowing, from appetizers, pasta, chicken, veal and dessert. The food and service were excellent and the staff was very accommodating.
9/27/2013 12:00:00 AM
I brought a group of eight
I brought a group of eight to Paul & Jimmy's after sampling some of their eats at the Taste of Gramercy event hosted by the Gramercy Neighborhood Association. This was our first time dining in the restaurant and we were very pleased. The food was delicious and the staff was extremely accomodating to our group. Our favorite dish was the eggplant rolatini. I'll definitely be back!
10/18/2013 12:00:00 AM
Wish SF had this place!
Love Paul and Jimmy's. Got introduced to it via The Taste of Gramercy - great charitable event.
The overall experience here is superb - excellent service, great food, wonderful cozy ambience.
A lovely spot for anyone IN or OUT of the neighborhood.
We dine here during our quarterly visits from San Francisco!
11/8/2013 4:00:00 PM