Maybe I ordered wrong?
I was so excited to go to New York Prime. What a treat. The ambiance is outstanding. I have never had better service in my life. The salad and cheesey mashed potatoes were wonderful. We had the baked shrimp appetizer and I felt the shrimp were a little over cooked. The flavor was nice though. For an entree my friend and I shared the lobster. I was so excited!! But I felt it was also a little over cooked and chewy... I should have gotten a steak. I will definitely go back, but it wasn't the best meal I've ever had.
3/17/2013 5:00:00 PM
Lived in Buckhead all my life
Lived in Buckhead all my life and frequent all the best steak places. This was one of teh best steaks i ever had. Bone in Rib Eye is wonderfull.Wasnt very impressed with sides but the steaks are to die for. and teh service was great.
4/3/2013 4:00:00 PM
The live music was too loud.
The live music was too loud. Made it hard to hear discussion at my business dinner.
4/7/2013 4:00:00 PM
Food was superb.better than
Food was superb.better than RUth CHris
As good as MYrtle BEach
I wish I could visit more often
4/7/2013 4:00:00 PM
Best Steaks around!
Best Steaks et al in the Country. IO have eaten in steak houses all over the U.S. and NY Prime ranks in the top 3 no question. The Bone-in Ribeye is the best.
4/7/2013 4:00:00 PM
NYP accommodated our large
NYP accommodated our large group as they do each year we visit the area for the Masters week! They are a superb restaurant from top to bottom. The service is impeccable and the food fantastic. They always make us feel welcome and the combination of superior service and food experience is why we keep returning each year!
4/9/2013 4:00:00 PM
When my wife and I visit ATL
When my wife and I visit ATL we always try to have dinner here. The Sea Bass and NY Strip are our favorites.
The service and food is always exceptional.
Steve & Sandy from Knoxville.
4/19/2013 4:00:00 PM
Our favorite place for steaks
Our favorite place for steaks and chops in the city. Never disappointed.
5/17/2013 4:00:00 PM
Excellant Steaks - Service Lacking
New York Prime has some of the best steaks around period. This was my first visit to the Buckhead NY Prime, I go to the one located in Myrtle Beach at least once a year. The food was great as anticipated however the service at this location was no where near the level provided in Myrtle Beach. Can't be sure if our waiter was hard of hearing or simply was not paying attention. The drink order a simple "Crown and Diet" was messed up by just being Crown. When it was pointed out that I had requested Crown and Diet he returned with a full glass of Diet Coke leaving me with a full glass of Crown and a full glass of Diet Coke. Despite the service shortcomings the steaks made it a great night! Would definitely recommend this restaurant.
5/17/2013 4:00:00 PM
Great steak and seafood. A
Great steak and seafood. A real classic dining spot.
5/20/2013 4:00:00 PM
Celebrated 28 years of marriage with a wonderful dinner at NY Prime. All aspects were top notch.
6/6/2013 4:00:00 PM
Always a treat!
New York Prime is our favorite steakhouse anywhere...including New York! The quality of the steak is superb. Knives go through them like butter. The salads and sides are yummy. Service is always excellent. Never had any thing but a wonderful experience at NY Prime.
6/9/2013 12:00:00 AM
The server was great and the
The server was great and the bartenders superb very friendly and helpful with what do to do in buckhead
6/12/2013 4:00:00 PM
Great way to start a vacation
Had just arrived in Atlanta from the West Coast and wanted an "old school" steakhouse meal. NYP was easy walking distance from the Westin and we like the website. The manager, Bobby, gave us a nice quiet table in the corner and kept us posted on the ice hockey game score. Our waiter Bryce was nicely attentive and knew his stuff. Impressive wine list and the steaks were some of the best we ever have had. Giant baked potato and mushrooms rounded out the meal. Found out from Bobby that NY Prime is part of a group of restaurants in the East. Will definitely seek out some of the others and would definitely visit NYP in Buckhead next time we are in Atlanta.
6/15/2013 12:00:00 AM
Celebrated my husband's 29th
Celebrated my husband's 29th birthday here. It was on Father's Day so the crowd was interesting- mostly families, lots of kids. They weren't that busy, but the hostess was nowhere to be seen for the first five minutes when we walked in. One star knocked off for the service. The food, however, was very good and rivaled any great steakhouse in Atlanta. Best mashed potatoes in town. My husband got a complimentary dessert, cigar, and card. They had a live singer/guitarist which was a nice touch. This is a small restaurant, but we didn't have a problem with the cigar smell at all like some others have mentioned. Oh, and the cheesecake is from Carnegie Deli in NY. To die for good!! All in all, glad we celebrated there- wonderful evening.
6/16/2013 12:00:00 AM
From the Maitre'D to the wait people filling our water glasses, the service was even a little better than the food (which was outstanding). The lady who was our waitress, was always attentive and never overbearing with perfect timing and always kept an eye on our table and responded to our every need.
She even went out of her way to bring my lady a special birthday treat!
Even though we live on the opposite side of Atlanta, the New York Prime Steakhouse has become our most favorite location for those special occasions.
6/22/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great food. The band was a
Great food. The band was a little too loud. We had a great time.
7/5/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great place, never disappoints
They say you get what you pay for, and this is certainly the case at New York Prime. It isn't cheap, but it is good. Service is also impeccable. One of the best in Atlanta.
The ONLY downside is that they allow smoking in the adjoining bar. I am sure this is a big plus if you are a smoker, but if you are not (and bothered by smoke) it makes the bar area unusable and despite the excellent ventilation the smell does come into the restaurant.
7/6/2013 12:00:00 AM
the food is great and the service is even better great place for a nice romantic dinner
7/11/2013 12:00:00 AM
One of my favorites in Buckhead
The Stakes and Seafood are excellent. Great Oysters, Great Food, Great Service.
Music in the Bar area is Great!
7/11/2013 12:00:00 AM
When we want to have an outstanding
When we want to have an outstanding meal, we go to NYP. It never disappoints. It doesn't try to be all things to all people and we like that. Good drinks at a good price. Simply the best steak house in Atlanta. We have gone on our anniversary the last several years and we both like it. If it "ain't " broke, don't fix it. NYP is not broke.
7/26/2013 12:00:00 AM
Father Son Night Out
When you are trying to expose your teen son to the "the finer things in life", there is no better place and no better host than New York Prime and Bobby Donlan! My son had the 14oz Center Filet cut that was cooked to perfection and I had the 22oz bone-in Ribeye also perfect. Our sides were of course the Cheese Mashed Potatoes and we added Steak Fries which we did not touch as we over ordered a bit. However we did share a piece of Cheesecake from the Carnegie Deli in NY. Our server Nathan was also the perfect person to make my son's first trip to NY Prime a memorable one.
7/29/2013 12:00:00 AM
Lot of Food
Best to share, wish the portions were 1/2 sized. Everything was great
7/30/2013 12:00:00 AM
Service means everything
The house salad was special, chilled,
Crisp and not over dressed. Breads were
Delicious. Steaks, veal & lamb chops pre
pared perfectly. Apple walnut pie delicious.
Didn't like smoking at the bar. Band was
terrific, single malt scotch was top shelf.
8/2/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great steak - relaxed atmosphere
The steaks were fantastic. I ordered the 14 oz. filet and they cooked the softball to a perfect M-R. My buddy had the ribeye that was also seasoned and cooked perfectly. Across the board the food was great.
This is a high-dollar steakhouse that is a magnet for cigar smokers. This is NOT a romantic or family place. It's great for a scotch, great food and or smoke though. It's like a well catered club house.
8/6/2013 12:00:00 AM
Atmosphere, Service and Food rise above your expectations. Also, the music/band are really good.
8/9/2013 12:00:00 AM
My first visit was fabulous.
My first visit was fabulous. The atmosphere was very comfortable. The salad great, the filet fabulous. I tried a white and red wine, both were very pleasing.- good selection..
8/16/2013 12:00:00 AM
Steaks are a little on the
Steaks are a little on the pricey side compared to other restaurants in Buckhead. Celebrated our anniversary and had a great time.
8/17/2013 12:00:00 AM
One of the top five steaks I've had in Atlanta. The atmosphere is near perfect for dining with just the right mix and a very attentive and professional staff.
8/23/2013 12:00:00 AM
Service was very excellent. Waiter was very attentive and food was delicios! Will return again!
8/24/2013 12:00:00 AM
Perfect for Father-Son Dinner
I selected NY Prime for a special father-son dinner the evening before the Chick Fil A Kickoff game (Roll Tide!). My 37 year old son and I had a very enjoyable evening with drinks, cigars and the 40 oz porterhouse for two. We both agreed that we'd return prior to next year's game.
8/30/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great food and excellent service.
Great food and excellent service. The baked shrimp was superb and my steak was cooked almost to perfection.
The manager and all the waiters that came to our table were very friendly and helpful.
The apple pie was also very good, and I want to go back to try the cheese cake.
8/31/2013 12:00:00 AM
Energetic Fine Dining
It was a delightful evening. Really nearly perfect in my mind. The steaks are available in many sizes so you can get the size you like and they were deliciously cooked! All of the staff were super friendly. I can't wait to go back.
9/14/2013 12:00:00 AM
Everything was great. The steaked was cooked perfectly. Everything hot, including corn onions and fries. Service excellent. Courtney is a gem.
9/21/2013 12:00:00 AM
We are experienced New York Prime Diners. Over the years, we have had many wonderful meals at NYP in Myrtle Beach. Have dined in Atlanta NYP only three times in our recollection but had a wonderful time this past weekend. Service and food was tops. Our first seating there was at a table with very poor lightning so we moved to another table and everything was fine. We did notice the people who followed us at the first table were using their cell phones to supplement their lighting for menu reading. You might want to revisit that issue.
9/21/2013 12:00:00 AM
love this place
only issue is the let people smoke at the bar so if you are not a smoker, beware the cigar smoke
9/22/2013 12:00:00 AM
Best steakhouse I've been to, and best restaurant that I've tried in Atlanta. It handily beats out Atlanta fish market, rays, ocean prime, prime, even chops and bones. You won't be disappointed.
9/24/2013 12:00:00 AM
My buddies and i were visiting from out of town and always like to try the best steak houses in each city. New York Prime is definitely a top tier steak house. Great food and service. Everything was cooked perfectly. We would definitely come back when we are in Atlanta.
9/24/2013 12:00:00 AM
The food was good, however I do not like to eat in the same area where there is smoking! Big negative for us!
9/25/2013 12:00:00 AM
We had good wine, good cocktails and good food. I liked the variety of wine by the glass. The service is spectacular. From the chef- who came to our table- to the waiters and bartenders, everyone takes real ownership in providing a great experience.
The steaks are seasoned too heavily.
9/26/2013 12:00:00 AM
My husband and I were celebrating
My husband and I were celebrating our 19th wedding anniversary when we went to New York Prime. We had a great time. The food was wonderful and wait staff extremely attentive.
9/27/2013 12:00:00 AM
Great Steak and service. Will definitely come back when I'm in town.
9/28/2013 12:00:00 AM
New York Prime Review
We had a company meeting at New York Prime this past Wedesnday and had a great dining experience. The food and service was outstanding. Thank you again!
10/9/2013 12:00:00 AM
Always excellent food and service. Steaks cooked to perfection, and awesome sides- loved the cheese mashed potAtoes.
May have to work on their ventilation system. We were far from the bar, but there was a heavy odor of cigar smoke, which for a non-smoker took away from the experience and made the meal less enjoyable. Also very heavy cigar stench at the restaurant entrance, which we had to pass thru, and the bar was not even crowded...
10/13/2013 12:00:00 AM
We told our waiter that we were having an annual get-together and wanted to talk. He managed our excellent champagne/food so that we never felt rushed. He was friendly and accommodating without being intrusive. The food, as always, was superior. I am addicted to the filets and mine was fabulous, and cooked exactly right. My friend ate two of the special menu items that evening--the spicy soup and the scallops over succotash--delicious. We shared an amazing warm bread pudding with Jack Daniels ice cream. The restaurant was busy but not rushed, not too loud for conversation, and I noticed an amazing phenomenon: I saw no one looking at a handheld device!--a clear sign that people came to enjoy the food and each other. Kudos!
10/23/2013 12:00:00 AM
It was a great atmoshpere
It was a great atmoshpere and a very "fancy" place to take someone or a group for special occoasion. I was there celebrating my birthday. i would definitely recommend it to a friend and prbably go back there agaon one day.
11/1/2013 5:00:00 PM
The food and service were impeccable. I almost canceled our reservation due to reviews on the smoking at the bar. As someone who is ultra sensitive to smoke, it was subtly detectable upon arrival and barely a trace after being placed at the far end of the room. FYI- We were told that the smoke is worse on the weeknight than weekends. All in all, we thoroughly enjoyed our meal, our waitstaff was fun and attentive (not overly so) and we will be back!!
11/1/2013 5:00:00 PM
Overall, we had great service, the food was delicious as New York Prime will continue to be our meeting spot for business meetings. Thank you and we look forward to our next experience!!
11/21/2013 4:00:00 PM
Delicious food and exceptional service. Above our budget for regular visits, but at top of the list as a go to place for special occasions.
11/26/2013 4:00:00 PM
Our server Heather was fantastic! She definitely help make it a memorable evening. Also, there was another attendant to our table and he was great, always kept our table neat and orderly and was practically invisible. Excellent service, excellent ambience, AMAZING STEAK! It was pretty pricy but a great choice for a special occasion!
11/29/2013 4:00:00 PM