TimeOut New York
Powered By OpenTable: Restaurant Reservations. Right this way.

Restaurant Reservations - Free • Instant • Confirmed

  • Online Reservations

Top 50 Italian Cuisine Restaurants - 2009 Diners' Choice Winners
An owner of a famous Italian restaurant on OpenTable once said “we get diners in the door with our name, but we keep them with the plate!” Just thinking about plates of risotto, osso bucco, brick-oven pizza or house-made pasta has our stomachs growling. Since the founding of our country, Italian food has been an essential part of our food culture.

We asked OpenTable diners to pick their favorite Italian restaurants – certainly not an easy task with all the great Italian restaurants we have on OpenTable! The result is our 2009 Diners’ Choice list of the Top 50 Italian restaurants in the United States.

So check out the list below, and why not dine Italian tonight? We bet you won’t leave hungry!

See monthly top restaurant lists in your area

Find out more details on OpenTable Diners’ Choice lists

2009 Best Italian Cuisine Winners - Top 50 Restaurant List


Restaurant Name
City
State
Reserve Now
AcquerelloSan FranciscoCAReserve Now
Angelina's RistoranteBonita SpringsFLReserve Now
BariMemphisTNReserve Now
Bella MonicaRaleighNCReserve Now
Bistro 5West MedfordMAReserve Now
Boca CincinnatiCincinnatiOHReserve Now
BordinosFayettevilleARReserve Now
Cafe JuanitaKirklandWAReserve Now
Cafe LucciGlenviewILReserve Now
Café NapoliClaytonMOReserve Now
Casa D' AngeloFort LauderdaleFLReserve Now
Charlie Gitto's 'On the Hill'St. LouisMOReserve Now
FalaiNew YorkNYReserve Now
FascinoMontclairNJReserve Now
Gabriel's RestaurantSedaliaCOReserve Now
Garozzo's RistoranteKansas CityMOReserve Now
Il CapriccioWalthamMAReserve Now
Il Mito EnotecaWauwatosaWIReserve Now
Il MulinoLas VegasNVReserve Now
Il MulinoAtlantic CityNJReserve Now
La CicciaSan FranciscoCAReserve Now
La MedusaSeattleWAReserve Now
Luca D'ItaliaDenverCOReserve Now
Luciano'sWrenthamMAReserve Now
Maggiano'sCharlotteNCReserve Now
Maggiano'sIndianapolisINReserve Now
Maggiano'sNashvilleTNReserve Now
Maggiano'sRichmond HeightsMOReserve Now
Michaelangelo'sClevelandOHReserve Now
Nicola's RistoranteCincinnatiOHReserve Now
No. 9 ParkBostonMAReserve Now
Osteria MozzaLos AngelesCAReserve Now
Pizzeria MozzaLos AngelesCAReserve Now
PrimavistaCincinnatiOHReserve Now
Restaurant AlbaMalvernPAReserve Now
Ristorante BartolottaWauwatosaWIReserve Now
RoSal'sChicagoILReserve Now
Sapori TrattoriaChicagoILReserve Now
Scalini FedeliNew YorkNYReserve Now
SorrentoHoustonTXReserve Now
Sotto SottoAtlantaGAReserve Now
Spezia OmahaOmahaNEReserve Now
SpiaggiaChicagoILReserve Now
SugoDuluthGAReserve Now
Tony's Di NapoliNew YorkNYReserve Now
ToscaHinghamMAReserve Now
Tosca RistoranteWashington, DCDCReserve Now
Trattoria LisinaDriftwoodTXReserve Now
Trattoria RomanaBoca RatonFLReserve Now
VetriPhiladelphiaPAReserve Now