Pelagia TrattoriaMothers Day BrunchWe were greeted very nicely when we arrived. We were a party of seven for the Mothers Day Brunch and we were seated at 2 p.m. Our server was most attentive to our table (which included 3 children) The food display was done very nicely with an amazing assortment of salads, cheeses, antipastos, and entrees. The prime rib and chicken piccata were outstanding, as were the pizza station and the Italian station (after 3 p.m.) Our grandchildren enjoyed the "make a pancake" for Mom and were given adorable chef hats for the process. It was in the Renaissance Hotel, which has very pretty outdoor courtyards and plantings along with beautiful palms...very tropical. I would definitely return.5/12/2013 12:00:00 AMIt was Mother's Day Brunch,It was Mother's Day Brunch, so a little chaotic. The kid (Chris maybe?) snapping his gum, assuring people their table was just being set, when there were delays(you needed a team of 2 flipping tables/setting tables you had your waiters and waitresses trying to do it in between customers) probably wasn't the best person, nor reassuring to have him at the helm. He kept running back and forth to the lady and the banter between the 2 of them probably shouldn't have happened in front of standing hungry customers. But worth the wait, the Prime Rib was excellent. Food overall very good, could have used 1 or 2 more starches had Roasted Potatoes and that was it (Risotto; Wild Rice; Whipped Sweet Potatoes would have been nice).5/12/2013 12:00:00 AMMother's Day BrunchThis was the second time that we had selected this restaurant for the celebration of Mother's Day. We went back because our first experience three years ago was very good. Pelagia Trattoria did not disappoint the second time around either. Wide array of selections, including a wonderful pancake station and equally impressive omelet station. Our server was fantastic. This one will stay on our Mother's Day play list.5/12/2013 12:00:00 AMVery goodGood food. Caesar fondue was playful and inventive. Nice experience for my boyfriend and I. Thanks to our server Lee who made it a wonderful meal.5/8/2013 12:00:00 AMEverything was great exceptEverything was great except went it came time to pay. They automatically added a tip of 18% for a party of six. OK, unusual, but that would have been fine. EXCEPT the server never mentioned it to anyone. When the bills were presented (it was split so there were two) absolutely no mention of that fact. Each party added a 20% tip on the final amount without noticing the 18% already on the bills. In on case that amounted to an additional $35.00 on the other $20.00. Exiting the parking lot the bill was reviewed and the compound tip was discovered. Be aware there is a trap on their bills. We won't return.4/24/2013 12:00:00 AMdecent placeVery difficult to say, this one is thrown out from the rest of the restaurants in bay street. Others looked more vibrant. This place is not bad but there are other places in the bay street which looked more attractive. There is nothing great to make go there again4/14/2013 12:00:00 AMPelagia...magnifico!The ceasar fondue was most memorable. The bar tender is gracious, friendly and made me feel at home while dining alone. Try the homemade pastas......simply the best!4/13/2013 12:00:00 AMLoved the food, presentation,Loved the food, presentation, service and ambience.3/29/2013 12:00:00 AMAbsolutly amazing I came inAbsolutly amazing I came in for dinner last week and enjoyed every secound of my stay, and they told me about the buffet that they offer on holidays. I gave it a try and it blew me away. Way more than I expected and the service was over the top for a buffet style of dinning. Price was moderate and the overall experience was amazing.3/26/2013 12:00:00 AMWay beyond the ordinary....Not your typical Italian restaurant in the fact that this goes way beyond typical. The service was outstanding from the smiling host to the manager and chefs walking around talking to everyone. He even convienced me to try their infused grappa. I didn't even know what grappa was and I left with my palate wanting more, except I had to drive. The food was good and you could tell everything was fresh. They even have a herb garden on their patio for their recipies. I truly enjoyed the great hospitality and will make sure to have it on my list for the next time I am in Tampa. A great find that leaves you wanting more.3/12/2013 12:00:00 AMMy partner and I had an exceptionalMy partner and I had an exceptional dinner and our server was supburb! Looking forward to our next dinner at Pelagia Trattoria.3/11/2013 12:00:00 AMThe food and service wereThe food and service were exceptional and we thoroughly enjoyed the entire experience. This was a special occasion for us and we were treated to extra special treats! We will certainly return for future occasions and will share this gem with others. Thanks to Chef Christian and our server, Ally, for the special attention.1/1/0001 4:00:00 PM