Old Homestead Restaurant
Consistently the most fabulousConsistently the most fabulous shrimp, steak and sides along with par excellent service.5/16/2013 12:00:00 AMGreat steaks with a twistThis was without doubt the best T-bone I ever ate. Tender and seared to perfection.
The twist was a Cajun style seasoning that added to the taste.
Pleasant ambiance and perfect service5/9/2013 12:00:00 AMAlways solidGreat apps, and of course great steaks. Never disappoints5/9/2013 12:00:00 AMOne of the bestI've eaten here on several occasions and leave impressed everytime. This is easily one of the top steakhouses in NYC. The only complaint I have is that it took 45 minutes for us to be seated despite having made reservations well in advance. Based on the number of people waiting in the very narrow corridor/bar area, it seemed as if they overbook purposely. Great experience otherwise.5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMperfect means PERFECT!World class food quality and presentation. Service staff is all about SERVICE and devoted insuring your every moment is pleasantly memorable. Only distance prevents more frequent visits.5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMService was good but foodService was good but food was not as good as expected and bad compared to other steak restaurants in NYC4/28/2013 12:00:00 AMVery good steakhouseWe were looking for a replacement to Ben Bensons. Unfortunately we didn't find it here. (We may never find a replacement) The food is very good, however, & I would recommend Old Homestead to everyone reading this review.
We had reservations at 9:30 PM & the place was packed with people. Got seated about 9:50. Not bad. Had a very good experience & our waitress was pleasant & accommodating. Was shocked to see a sonoma county wine on the list. It was fantastic with our steaks.
It's not Ben Bensons but it is very good. Recommended4/27/2013 12:00:00 AMThe Food and the Service wasThe Food and the Service was outstanding. Best steaks in the US !!4/12/2013 12:00:00 AMI was in New York with myI was in New York with my brother for the Eric Clapton Crossroads Guitar Festival and my brothers 50th birthday. I wanted to take my brother for a special meal and decided on the Old Homestead Restaurant I have to say it has been a long time since I had a great steak like the one I ate. We had a great night and would love to say Thank You to all the staff. Looking forward to my next trip in New York with my wife so I can be back to visit The Old Homestead Restaurant4/11/2013 12:00:00 AMCan't Wait to Return!!Returned to this restaurant with a friend after eating there for the first time with a group six months ago. The food was a good as I remembered. The steaks are so tender and the truffle mac and cheese is out of this world. It was so good we had to have two orders. Your dinner will be expensive .....but worth it.4/8/2013 12:00:00 AMI think it would be difficultI think it would be difficult to find a better steak than the porterhouse at the Old Homestead.4/6/2013 12:00:00 AMDelicious steaksThe 22 oz. Gotham Rib steak was cooked really well! I had the hand cut french fries and the string beans with carmelized onions and pancetta, all were yummy! My starter, oysters rockefeller was delicious but the rock salt sprinkled around the plate could prove treacherous for the unsuspecting diner. The table was roomy enough for three of us but my husband's steak was sent back because he asked for medium well and got my medium. He sent it back, they were gracious and brought it back with an extra side of mashed potatoes. So, try it, it's fun. If you like it, recommend it.4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMThis was my second time thereThis was my second time there and I have not been disappointed. I had the Kobe Burger and it was amazing. The tater tots were the best I have ever had. Great wine selection and they make excellent drinks. Will absolutely come back again for more deliciousness!4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMWe've always wanted to comeWe've always wanted to come here because it's reputed to be one of NY's premier steakhouses. We were not disappointed. Although all things considered I think I preferred the porterhouse for two at some of its peers, we really enjoyed the taste of the meat, which was cooked precisely as we ordered it (black and blue). The sliced bacon was great, as was the lump crabmeat appetizer. The tables for two upstairs are close to one another, so you may wind up making friends with your neighbors, but for those of you that enjoy intimacy, you can keep to yourself if you want to.4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMA touch of classThis was my first "taste" of The Old Homestead.We had reservations for noon. We were the onlyones in there so we sat immediately. It was cleanand pleasant. Furnished with wood accents whitetablecloths and linens. Wait staff was in black andwhite.We started with a glass of Shiraz. Server wasfriendly and professional. My husband had the filet wrapped in baconand I had the sliders. We each had the onionsoup, best I ever had!All in all a delightful experience.4/2/2013 12:00:00 AMget the Kobe burger special!One word incredible had the Kobe burger lunch special looked small but could not finish all I will be back!3/31/2013 12:00:00 AMThe meals were outstandingThe meals were outstanding in taste and simple presentation.The best steak period. The service was very attentive. Great energy throughout the dining room with a great mix of patrons. We prefer Old Homested over The Palm and Peter Luegers.3/30/2013 12:00:00 AMI have tried others, but OldI have tried others, but Old Homestead is hands-down the best steakhouse in New York...Period.3/29/2013 12:00:00 AMGreat Service,Great FoodService was fantastic! The staff was so friendly and attentive. The food was excellent!3/28/2013 12:00:00 AMWhen talking about the OldhomesteadWhen talking about the Oldhomestead you are talking about the best steak house in New York City.The service is great. When checking in for your reservation they are very friendly and polite.When I go there I always get the Prime rib,it is so tender and the flavor is out of this world.One of the sides to get is the mac & cheese.
I have just one hint about this place,come hungry because when you leave I am sure you will not eat for a long time.3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMFood was amazing! We wereFood was amazing! We were seated 15 minutes past our reservation, but the waitstaff and manager were great!3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMOverall, the experience wasOverall, the experience was excellent. However, the kitchen ran out of the lobster we wanted and the key lime pie for dessert. This was very disappointing.3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMDon't miss this restaurant!One of the best meals in NYC. Very pricey but save up and go. Don't buy that extra blouse this week. The men had steaks which were FAB. My friend and I split the sea bass, another FAB!. We all shared the crab cake and it was the best I'd ever had.3/15/2013 12:00:00 AMWe made reservations at 8:30We made reservations at 8:30 on a Friday night and did not sit down until 10 pm. Would of been ok if we did not have our 7 & 10 year old girls with us. Not kid friendly at all. We are from Houston visiting and always looking for great restaurants. Food was fantastic and hostess was very friendly. Would recommend be prepared for a long wait.3/15/2013 12:00:00 AMIt was a wonderful evening.It was a wonderful evening. Great salads. We had good seating. We will be back.it is too noisy3/14/2013 12:00:00 AMGreat Vegas findI love the food I get here. The giant meatball on the appetizer menu is amazing. Last time, there were some Kobe beef skewers on the menu for the night that were worth every penny. Every time we are Vegas, we make an effort to go here.1/1/0001 4:00:00 PM