Powered By OpenTable: Restaurant Reservations. Right this way.

Restaurant Reservations - Free • Instant • Confirmed

  • Online Reservations

Shelter Island Restaurants

Change Location ›

Make a Free Restaurant Reservation

  • Restaurant List
  • Best Restaurants

Shelter Island Restaurants

Vine Street Cafe photo.jpg
Vine Street Cafe
Shelter Island | American
40 Reviews
La Maison Blanche photo.jpg
La Maison Blanche
Shelter Island | French
7 Reviews
18 Bay photo.jpg
18 Bay
Shelter Island | Italian
13 Reviews

Shelter Island Diners' Choice Winners

Shelter Island's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Vine Street Cafe photo.jpgDiners' Choice Winner: Best Food
Vine Street Cafe
Shelter Island | American
40 Reviews

The OpenTable Blog: Dining Check

On Our Plate: Restaurant Weeks in Cincinnati +... Obamacare’s Effect on Restaurants; Wine Mark-ups Explained; Will Local...
Happenings on and around OpenTable… * OpenTable for Android 2.5 is here. Find out... Dining news from around the web and the world… * How not to respond to restaurant criticism on social media. Let this be a...
05/15/2013 05/15/2013

ADVERTISEMENT

You Might Like

New York Area restaurants to try based on OpenTable diner ratings
The Frog and the Peach photo.jpg
The Frog and the Peach
 149 Reviews
New Brunswick | American
Michael Anthony's Waterfront photo.jpg
Michael Anthony's Waterfront
 39 Reviews
Jersey City | Italian

OpenTable diners are saying

Long Island / Hamptons restaurant reviews from diners
  • Thyme
    129 reviews
    Roslyn | Contemporary American
    Attentive staff, nice menu options, good food, charming decor
    OpenTable diner  5/16/2013
  • Vittorio's Restaurant & Wine Bar
    60 reviews
    Amityville | Continental
    My experience at Vittorio's was lovely! The food was great and Dave, our waiter, was such a delight!!! My girlfriend and I had a chance to sample different wines with each course which was most enjoyable. This was my second time at Vittorio's and definitely won't be my last....More
    OpenTable diner  5/16/2013
  • Sole
    36 reviews
    Oceanside | Italian
    First time at Sole and went to celebrate my birthday. We all had different dishes and each was amazing and delicious. A wonderful experience and truly made for a great birthday! Thanks Sole for a terrific celebration! I will definitely return!...More
    OpenTable diner  5/16/2013