Shelter Island Restaurants

Change Location ›

Make a Free Restaurant Reservation

  • Restaurant List
  • Best Restaurants

Shelter Island Restaurants

18 Bay photo.jpg
18 Bay
Shelter Island | Italian
57 reviews
Vine Street Cafe photo.jpg
Vine Street Cafe
Shelter Island | American
68 reviews

Shelter Island Diners' Choice Winners

Shelter Island's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
Vine Street Cafe photo.jpgDiners' Choice Winner: Fit for Foodies
Vine Street Cafe
Shelter Island | American
68 reviews
18 Bay photo.jpgDiners' Choice Winner: Fit for Foodies
18 Bay
Shelter Island | Italian
57 reviews
  • Welcome to OpenTable

  • Create an account to earn Points toward free meals.