Mitch & Toni’s American Bistro
lovely eveningFirst time here... My husband had the prix fix dinner I ordered a la carte although we both had the same entree pan fried striped bas.. With couscous and zucchini.. I had a heirloom tomato salad with watermelon and we shared his dessert of 3 flavors of sorbet... We went early so that we could get over to our grandchildren's house to babysit so their parents could go out for dinner.... We had early reservations and we were alone until we were almost done.. About 7 ish and then the place started getting busy.. Wonderful staff and great food we shall return...6/15/2013 12:00:00 AMI can always count on a goodI can always count on a good meal...done my way. They are very agreeable about substitution. My husband doesn't eat carbs, and they happily substituted stringbeans for his potato.6/12/2013 12:00:00 AMvery good food, music too loudThis was our second time to Mitch & Toni's, and the food was very good, though it is priced like a Manhattan restaurant. The wine list has several selections that are fairly priced. It was a Friday evening and there was a good musical combo playing during dinner. The problem was that they we so loud you couldn't hear across the table. Dinner music is great, this was more suitable for a bar.6/7/2013 12:00:00 AMDelicious, tasty lunch - whatDelicious, tasty lunch - what a nice break in the middle of the day. Mitch & Tony's is a wonderful restaurant with tasty, appetizing choices.6/5/2013 12:00:00 AMDelicious!!I have gone here several times with my family, and each time the food has been delicious and flavorful. Weel made with great ingredients. My most recent I had a wonderful experience with the co-owner. She went above and beyond to help my 2 year old to stop crying from her skinned Knees. She was very warm and personable. Which makes me want to go back cause we felt so welcome. And because of the Yummy food!6/2/2013 12:00:00 AMLoved itHad a gift card and hadnt had a chance to use it. When I saw the reservation slot on Open Table, I figured it was finally time. So glad we went there Saturday night. Great restaurant. Will definitely add this to our Saturday night rotation!6/1/2013 12:00:00 AMImproved menuThey've improved their menu and it's now replete with more eclectic and exciting dishes.5/25/2013 12:00:00 AMSooooo Good!Great restaurant...innovative dishes with a high standard for quality. Reservation was honored & we sat upon arrival.
A must go to place on Long Island.5/11/2013 12:00:00 AMConsistently Very GoodMitch and Toni's continues to excel and get better. Although usually very good, the service was excellent and the food wonderful. A great neighborhood find with great food. ON Thursday's BYO bottle with no corkage. Life is good.5/9/2013 12:00:00 AMabsolutely love this restaurant.absolutely love this restaurant. the food in innovative and delicious. they are always will ing to accomodate any special requests. i was there on a sat. evening and i went early to avoid the crowds and noise and just loved it.5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMThis was my first visit toThis was my first visit to this restaurant and we were all pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food.
The service was very good and the food well prepared. There was only one thing that slightly disappointed us. Our reservation was for a Saturday night and we were able to order from the prix fixe menu. However, the menu that was shown online was not the same as what was offered that evening. The waiter told us that this "early bird" menu shown online was only representative of the type of food served and did not represent the actual menu. Otherwise I would highly recommend Mitch & Toni's and I'm sure we will go back in the future.5/4/2013 12:00:00 AMMy friend and I had a deliciousMy friend and I had a delicious meal with wonderful service!4/26/2013 12:00:00 AMgreat spot...nice trendy place...thgreat spot...nice trendy place...the service was excellent...will absolutley go again.4/8/2013 12:00:00 AMWow...We've eaten at Mitch & Toni's on several occasions and they 'wow' us every time. We started with a fun rounds of drinks including a blood-orange margarita and a jalapeño margarita. We kept it light for appetizers and had the felafel. What a treat...they were perfect! The entree selection offered a wide variety of choices pleasing to all palates. Our group had the pistachio crusted rack of lamb, grilled mahi mahi, the tuna special with three delicious dipping sauces and scrumptious BBQ beef short ribs. Even though we were kind of full, we couldn't resist dessert...the s'mores and dark chocolate semi-fredo were the perfect end to our wonderful meal. The staff are warm and friendly, and happy to accommodate you in any way they can.4/6/2013 12:00:00 AMWe have gone to Mitch & Toni'sWe have gone to Mitch & Toni's many time and love it. We bring our kids who, while teens, have watch one to many Chef Ramsay shows & have become quite the critics :) With two kids we try to keep it reasonable, & in the past it has been easier. Pre fixe was off which makes it hard. My little Ramsays order off the main entrees & we felt pressure to '+ it' but did not. We need to budget below $200 which is hard. Appetizers and desserts are slightly overpriced. Great, but overpriced. Entrees are top $ but well worth it. Of our 4 dinners the only weak item was the potato augratin serve under a NY strip. All tried it, so it's not just the tastes of a 13 y/o, it was a 'brick'. I notice portion size from table to table varied too much.4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMReliably EnjoyableAnother very good dining experience at Mitch & Toni's. Food was great as usual - tuna tartare appetizer and braised short ribs entrées, and peanut butter chocolate dessert were particularly delicious; prosciutto, fig & arugula flat bread pizza and duck were also very good. We had an early reservation on a Friday evening so it was not very crowded and thus not too loud - our previous dinners here have suffered from a rather noisy atmosphere due to few soft surfaces in the dining room. Overall, a very nice meal on our third visit, glad to have Mitch & Toni's so near to home.4/5/2013 12:00:00 AMFirst time at this restaurant,First time at this restaurant, went for the prix- fixed which is served from 4 pm-6:30 based on menu on website. Given menu in restaurant it was completely different, they said they change the menu every week. I was looking forward to the items on the menu I saw on the web site which included steak and cheesecake. The food was delicious, and beautifully presented. My friend does not like chocolate and all the desserts included chocolate. The main courses were two fish dishes and one chicken dish. Menu could have used more variety. All things considered, I would definitely go back but call first to,check on the prix fixed menu. Also enjoyed the Chardonnay and the coffee. There is live music on Thursday evening starting at 7 pm.4/4/2013 12:00:00 AMMy husband and I went on aMy husband and I went on a Thursday night date. It was a late afternoon decision after we received the BYOW email. We thought it was the perfect night. Brought a special bottle from home to enjoy a delicious meal. We were in no rush and were able to enjoy each course. We had the caesar with calamari and tuna tartare to start,lamb chops and salmon for dinner. Everything was so tasty! A special bonus, we had some great live background music. Always a great time at Mitch and Toni's.4/4/2013 12:00:00 AMOur meal was on Easter SundayOur meal was on Easter Sunday in the early evening. There were many family groups and when I looked at the menu, I saw why. Mitch and Toni's now has small, large and family sized meals! The tables are close, but people are respectful of space. The hostess and co-owner, Toni, always visits the tables. If you come here, your name is in the computer so that you are greeted as a regular which is nice. My husband and I always think of this when we go to a place more than once.
I had the roasted chicken, baked potato and delicious broccoli; Joe had duck. We shared mussels. We each had a glass of wine, but no dessert. Our bill came to about $100.
There is valet parking, even if it is raining, you don't get too wet. This is a nice local dining sp3/31/2013 12:00:00 AMgood food and serviceThe owners are very friendly and the service was great. Food is delicious. Great variety.3/24/2013 12:00:00 AMBeen here several times. NeverBeen here several times. Never fails to impress me. They now have a new 'market menu' which is extremely affordable and well worth it. Highly recommended.3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMThis was our first time andThis was our first time and this restaurant. We were seated promptly at our reservation time. The service was very attentive and the food was excellent. The flow of service was also very comfortable.3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMFirst time here; won't beFirst time here; won't be our last ! Food and wait staff were awesome ! Toni herself even stopped by to ask how our appetizer was. Awesome falafel! Can't wait to return!!3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMService was excellent. FromService was excellent. From the confirmation
Of our reservations to how we were given attention by our waitress Keri, we were pleased straight through. The food was delicious, SAMs was shared and divided for us( nice surprise). The mussels were light but plenty of sauce to soak up with the bread. Wine list was not ove done but complimented our food well. The salmon was just perfectly done. Dessert was fair. Overall a great local spot and defintely will return!!3/16/2013 12:00:00 AMDining at Mitch & Toni'sWe dined at Mitch & Toni's a few months ago and it was a delightful and unique experience. Upon arriving we were seated immediately at our table. Our waiter was very knowledgeable about the menu. We both ordered salads which were very good. My entree was a salmon dinner tastefully prepared with special vegetables, and my friend chose a pasta dinner. For dessert, we had cannolis which were also great. I would recommend this restaurant for its varied menu which changes seasonally, and the excellent service. Also they have valet parking.2/16/2013 12:00:00 AMvery pleasant experience.very pleasant experience. The service and food were excellent. Tables a little too close.
The menu had a good variety of choices. Will go back to try different choices. Good find.2/9/2013 12:00:00 AM