Powered By OpenTable: Restaurant Reservations. Right this way.
Restaurant Reservations - Free • Instant • Confirmed
  • Carriage House Restaurant

  • Online Reservations

Carriage House Restaurant
Carriage House Restaurant

Carriage House Restaurant Details

  • Dining Style: Casual Elegant
  • Website: http://www.papermill.org
  • Phone: (973) 315-1707
  • Hours of Operation: Dinner: Thursday-Saturday: 5:00pm - 9:00pm
    Sunday Brunch: 10:00am - 3:00pm
  • Payment Options: AMEX, MasterCard, Visa
  • Cuisine: Contemporary American, International, Tapas / Small Plates
  • Executive Chef: Holly Guber
  • Dress Code: Smart Casual
  • Accepts Walk-Ins: Yes
  • Additional Details: Banquet/Private Rooms, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Entertainment, Fireplace, Full Bar, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Private Room, Weekend Brunch, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Wine Bar
  • Entertainment: When the theatre is dark, The Carriage House has live piano and jazz music on Friday and Saturday nights.

Getting there

  • Cross Street: Main Street
  • Public Transit: We are located 4 blocks from the NJ Transit train stop in Millburn
  • Parking: Private Lot
  • Parking Details: There are several park & pay lots surrounding the theatre, and they are open for pre-show parking. When the theatre is dark, parking is free.
A word from Carriage House Restaurant
The Carriage House offers a fine dining a la carte menu during the weeks when the theater is not in production and prix-fixe, pre-theatre dining to Paper Mill patrons, directly across from the theatre entrance. Award-winning chef Holly Guber is proud to be at the helm of this newly renovated gem that is also open when the theatre is dark, with an eclectic menu of small and large plates, and a stunning selection of interesting wines by the glass.Continued
Foodspotting photos
See all photos >
Awards voted by OpenTable diners
  • Diners' Choice WinnerGreat for Lunch
Diner Reviews
  • "The Carriage House Restaurant is great for pre-theater lunch or dinner when seeing a play at Paper Mill Playhouse."
    Dined on 4/11/2014
  • "I don't think that everyone knows just how good this little piece of heaven's food tastes. We are always pleased with our 3 course lunches. The food is so fresh and delicious! Planning to bring my son and daughter-in-law here for a special birthday lunch during the next show. The staff is also very attentive and helpful, too."
    Dined on 4/10/2014
  • "This has become our favorite tradition before seeing one of the wonderful shows at the Paper Mill Playhouse. We make reservations well in advance for an early dinner leaving ourselves plenty of time to relax and enjoy the wonderful meal. We've never been disappointed - the meals and service are always great."
    Dined on 4/9/2014
  • "Convenient to the theater in Milburn, food and service were good but it was pricey and the brunch is a price fixe menu --no ala carte available. I will choose another restaurant in town next time for a pre-theater meal."
    Dined on 3/16/2014
  • "My reservation was for 4:15. we arrived at 4:00 and asked if we could sit at the bar and was told they didn't open until 4:30 but yes. There was a woman sitting at the bar on a computer who indicated to us they really were not open. she was very rude and outright showed how annoyed she was that we were there. the poor bartender was doing her best to make us feel comfortable. When i asked if there was a house wine the woman - in an annoyed voice told us NO only the wines listed on the wine list were available. I could clearly see wines behind the bar that were NOT on the wine menu. It really was the only thing about our visit that was not good. Every other person we encountered was wonderful and could not do enough for us. The food was good"
    Dined on 3/9/2014
  • "This restaurant is on the grounds of PaperMill Playhouse in Millburn. My husband and I brought another couple to dine here before the show. There is a prix-fixe menu with three choices for appetizer, entree, and dessert. The entire meal is $40 and the menu rotates as the show rotates. The food is always good here and the portions aren't monstrous. One of our party ordered a dessert item which had run out, so the restaurant offered a substitute, banana ice cream with whipped cream, a drizzle of chocolate sauce and macadamias. We all ordered it and it was delicious. The restaurant could have used one more server but the service was gracious and the view of the grounds is very nice."
    Dined on 3/15/2014
  • "We have typically gone to other restaurants in Millburn before attending the Papermill Playhouse. We decided to try the Carriage House. The food was very good but the fixed menu was very limited. The four of us ended up with the same main course because of the limited menu. They had a good wine list. It was VERY convenient for attending a show. The only thing they need to do is expand the menu somewhat. We also stopped in after the show for a nightcap to let the parking lot traffic empty out. They had a piano player at the bar which was very nice."
    Dined on 3/15/2014
  • "Went on a Saturday night, pre-show. 3 team wait staff was overwhelmed. One gave said "too many couples here tonight". Uh, this is the subirbs and you have a show next door--what would oen expect. Poor experience, would not waste the time or energy."
    Dined on 3/15/2014
  • "This is a perfect lunch stop before the show at the Papermill. The food is good - especially the desserts. After lunch you just walk across the street to the show."
    Dined on 3/13/2014
  • "food is very good, Nice ambiance. Espcially great if you are going to a show at the PaperMill"
    Dined on 3/12/2014
  • "We chose this restaurant for our pre show dinner for The Paper Mill Playhouse. Excellent choice for the timing and location."
    Dined on 3/12/2014
  • "Very good before the paper mill playhouse show. Good food and service"
    Dined on 3/6/2014
  • "Soup was delicious, salad looked uninspired, open faced blt was very good. Wait staff very nice."
    Dined on 3/6/2014
  • "This delightful gem, on the campus of the Paper Mill Playhouse is getting better and better. The chef is open to substitutes with your entree - food is fresh and presented beautifully. There is a great buzz in the atmosphere of theatre goers enjoying their meals and a great glass or bottle of wine. Bar is beautiful and cozy. Service is attentive and professional with the chef visiting the tables asking if there are any questions about the menu."
    Dined on 3/5/2014
  • "Charming restaurant, located on the grounds of the Papermill Plathouse. The pre-fixed menu was excellent and is reasonably prices. WE had the salad. Osso Buco and the salmon. very satiesfying and delicious meal. Service was a little slow that eveneing so we took home the dessert and enjoiyrd it later."
    Dined on 2/27/2014
  • "This restaurant located at the Papermill Playhouse, is quite good since the new Chef took over management. Everything served is very good. Service is good. The menu though understanadely limited offers a choice for everyone and for the most t part is quite healthy. Great for pre theater dinner since you only have to walk acroees the courtyard to the theater."
    Dined on 10/3/2013
  • "We had tickets for the evening show at the adjoining Paper Mill Playhouse, so we tried the Prix Fixe dinner at Carriage House. The food was good enough for Prix Fixe, and a decent value. The atmosphere is delightful, a charming old building with the modern updates to make dining comfortable. Very pleased to be seated by the fireplace on a chilly night. The service, however, was disappointing. A different person brought each course, which definitely affected the timing. We felt rushed, and there were free tables, so there was no reason for the rush. We will try the restaurant again."
    Dined on 3/1/2014
  • "Excellent restaurant, food is great and not your usual fare. Staff is charming and efficient. We go there before the show at PaperMill and enjoy the meal as much as the show!"
    Dined on 3/2/2014
  • "Having been attending performances at the Papermill since I was a child, I had never had dinner before a show, and I was so happy I did. What a pleasure to arrive at 6:00, park easily and then stroll into the theatre. The 3 course dinner was very good-I thoroughly enjoyed my green salad, salad and dessert. The wine selection, though limited, was very good. I would definitely suggest making this part of your eveing."
    Dined on 2/27/2014
  • "Very charming and relaxing atmosphere. Our group of six thoroughly enjoyed our pre-matinee lunch. The service was exceptional and we would most certainly return again."
    Dined on 2/27/2014
  • "We are matinee subscribers to the Paper mill ,and hoped to dine there frequently. However, the luncheon served at the Carriage House was poor. The soup, salad and dessert were good, but the entrees, except for the bread pudding, were almost inedible."
    Dined on 2/22/2014
  • "Nice staff and well-run restaurant. The price-fix menu choices were excellent and our waitress was very professional and pleasant, The price / value equation is very good. One suggestion - I'd add some lower cost bottles and glasses of wine to your inventory. Not everyone wants to pay $40+ for a bottle of wine. Should have some choices more in the $25-$30 range for both red and white bottles and per glass prices of $8 or so.."
    Dined on 2/21/2014
  • "I was on a detox diet for my fitness program and The Carriage House allowed me to order a prix fix lunch within my plan."
    Dined on 2/20/2014
  • "The food and convince are the draws here. Welcoming feeling needs to improve. Offering a second serving of rolls would be nice. So close to being a real gem."
    Dined on 2/19/2014
  • "When going to Millburn's PaperMill Playhouse, start your evening by going to the Carriage House. You can relax, and dine on great food and then just breeze right into the Playhouse. Makes the whole night feel like an event."
    Dined on 12/21/2013
  • "This is a nice, clean restaurant. The hostess was very nice and gave me the option of where I would like to sit. The Carriage House is right next to the Papermill Playhouse, so it is very convenient to park, dine and then see a play at the Papermill. The food was good, but there is a pre-fix menu before the play, and I wish there were more options."
    Dined on 12/21/2013
  • "I loved my food & 2 of the other 3 people thought their food was good. Unfortunately, my 80 year old mother is a picky eater & thought the soup was ok and the salad was one of the worst ones she's ever had - she picked at it and ate very little. Many of us like a "gourmet" meal that is eclectic but there are a number of people that don't. I think you should have one or two "simple" items on the menu (like a sandwich) for basic eaters. We will continue to go there before all the Paper Mill performances because the rest of us are usually very happy!"
    Dined on 12/22/2013
  • "The Carriage House is convenient for dinner when attending a show at the Papermill. The food portions are on the smaller side but usually tasty. The last time we were ther 12/2013 we were there for a 5:15 reservation and they ran out of ice cream...one of three dessert choices....how is that possible when there are at least 10 stores close by that carry ice cream...they were out of other selections as well and the menu is very limited...service was just ok."
    Dined on 12/4/2013
  • "Dinning is set up to feed guests and get them out for show time at Papermill Playhouse and they do it so well. We never felt pushed or rushed. My elderly mother enjoyed the setting the food and the service. When we were done we just walked over to the playhouse and enjoyed the rest of our day."
    Dined on 12/19/2013
  • "This restaurant is wonderful! Will go there again and again,"
    Dined on 12/15/2013
  • "A great way to meet for a papermill playhouse event! Food is great and reasonable. Love the ambience and service."
    Dined on 12/12/2013
  • "My son and I had a wonderful time at the Carriage House. Our server was very attentive. The food was delicious and we had a moment of non-hurried conversation before enjoying the theater at Paper Mill Playhouse. We felt so pampered. It was a fun to relax before watching the play."
    Dined on 12/8/2013
  • "had a wonderful time while enjoying great food and service."
    Dined on 12/6/2013
  • "The lunch menu was fabulous. The lobster bisque was so tasty. The bread pudding was delish and just the right amount. The star was the prosciutto goat cheese and fig bruschetta. It was amazing. The salad that came with it left a little to be desired though. Somewhat bland. The waitress took my plate before I was done so be sure to speak up. Overall great experience."
    Dined on 12/7/2013
  • "My mom and I decided to dine at the Carriage House before seeing the show at the Paper Mill Playhouse on Saturday night. The food was very good except for the cake which was stale. I knew it was going to be a fixed menu so I was not surprised. I can't see myself going back and certainly not if I wasn't seeing the show afterward. There are many very nice dinning places in the area to choose from. The biggest plus is the location; parking across the street and a 3 second walk to the Paper Mill."
    Dined on 12/7/2013
  • "The menu was very limited. No accommodation for special requests. Music too loud. The salad was miniscule with only lettuce and tomato ( requested unions, cheese, olives, mushrooms,etc. which were not available). Not worth the prices of the meals. ( My wife could not have dessert, because she is gluten free . All of the desserts contained flour, except for ice cream, which they were out of.) Prior to dinner upon having wine, she requested to have something to nibble on , but they had nothing."
    Dined on 12/7/2013
  • "Perfect for when you're going to a performance, but a good choice even when you're not!"
    Dined on 12/6/2013
  • "The restaurant was lovely, a very nice ambience. When we walked in there was a roaring fire and on a rainy dreary day it made you feel a lot better. The service was wonderful. A nice young girl who was very eager to make our visit pleasurable. The food was delicious, the price great! A three course lunch...I personally didn't want to eat a dessert...so she offered me a plate of fresh fruit, which was delicious, just what I wanted. and then after all that we only had to walk a few feet to the Papermill Playhouse and enjoy a great show! Thank you all for a really nice day..."
    Dined on 12/5/2013
  • "The food is very good, but not great. The service seems a bit too fast , but of course they want to make sure everybody gets out in time for the PaperMill show. In their situation, too slow would be a disaster, whiIe too fast is only a minor blemish. I would rate the ambiance higher, considering the building, the fireplace in one room and the decor, except there a bit too many tables. Which also leads to a loud environment. Overall, a very good, very convenient place to go before a show,"
    Dined on 12/4/2013
  • "Very nice atmosphere with good food. Right next door to Paper Mill Playhouse so it make a nice relaxing dining experience when attending a show. Menus changes with the shows."
    Dined on 12/4/2013