Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn

See all 103 Reviews ›

Address:
3539 Sagunto Street
Santa Ynez, CA 93460

Neighborhood:
Santa Ynez Valley

Getting there ›
Cuisine:
American

Price: $31 to $50

More Details ›

Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn Details

Dining Style: Fine Dining
Website: http://www.brothersredbarn.com
Phone: (805) 688-4142
Hours of Operation:

Lunch: Daily 11:30am-2:30pm

Dinner: Daily 5:00pm-9:00pm
Payment Options: AMEX, MasterCard, Visa
Cuisine: American, Steak, Seafood
Executive Chef: Matt and Jeff Nichols
Dress Code: Smart Casual
Accepts Walk-Ins: Yes
Additional Details: Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Farm to Table, Fireplace, Full Bar, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Private Room, Wine

Getting there

Cross Street: Edison Street
Parking: Private Lot

A word from Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn

The Nichols brothers, Matt & Jeff, grew up in Ames, Iowa where their love of cooking, good food and a sense of family and community was nurtured.

The 2013 opening of their second Santa Barbara Wine Country restaurant, Brothers Restaurant at the Red Barn in Santa Ynez, allows them to… offer visitors and locals alike great food, wine and hospitality. The brothers strive to have legendary service, innovative cuisine, and a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere that causes you to return time and again.

As chefs, the brothers continue to experiment with new dishes and cuisine, but always with that “from scratch”, homemade element. Fresh ingredients from local producers, a wine list that showcases the region’s award-winning wines and a comfortable and historically interesting atmosphere that takes you back to the romance of the old west. They want you to feel at home, and experience all the best of Santa Barbara’s Wine Country.Continued

Foodspotting photos

See all photos >

Awards voted by OpenTable diners

Diners' Choice WinnerBest Overall
Diners' Choice WinnerBest Ambiance
Diners' Choice WinnerBest Food

Diner Reviews

"Waiting for years for the Brothers to open something comparable to their menu at Mattei's Tavern. We were delighted to return to the Red Barn to discover that their food and new location is better than ever. (their Prime Rib is to die for!) We had a great evening there Sun night with friends and look forward to many more."
Dined on 3/9/2014
"Excellent filet. Tender and lots of flavor. Wife was equally impressed with her dish. Service was top notch. This is a must if you're in the area."
Dined on 2/28/2014
"We have been a follower of the Brother's for over 30 years. Their new location is the best yet. Great food, good service and nice location. If you're visiting the valley make it a must do."
Dined on 3/2/2014
"Instead of driving back to Santa Barbara to celebrate my Birthday, my beautiful fiancé Julie and I decided to stop in Santa Ynez and try out the Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn. I had tried them when they were over at Mattei's Tavern, and wanted to see how the food compared. Well, it was just as awesome as ever. We started with a "Mashed Potato" sampler, then on to the Vegetable Spring Rolls, followed by Scottish Salmon for myself and the Filet Mignon with Scalloped Potatoes for Julie. And a wonderful special dessert to finish. The food was perfect, the inside decor was very nice, and our server, Staci, was incredible. It was a perfect Birthday dinner and we can't wait to go back!"
Dined on 3/2/2014
"Would like to see them expand the menu. Good steak but a little $$$"
Dined on 2/23/2014
"Once again the Nichols Brother opened another successful restaurant and bringing more business to Santa Ynez. Even though it was to be a similar menu to the Brothers Restaurant at Matteis Tavern, I found the recipes and quality of the food to be off or not what I remembered. It is a little pricey for me but it still is excellent food, dessert is yummy and the wine list is very good. The manager is great, very welcoming and the wait staff was good, always checked on how we were doing even if they weren't our waiters. Message to Open Table. They received my reservation for one and I was confirmed from you for two."
Dined on 2/22/2014
"We dined on Friday with two other couples who also frequent the Red Barn. We booked three days ahead and most of "prime" time was taken. We had a 5:30 which was perfect for six people to gather and order before the crowd. The restaurant has been beautifully remodeled and the food is consistently excellent. I had the scallop special and my husband had prime rib. He ate all of his and I took half of mine home. The split the Spring Rolls as an appetizer and two desserts were split by the table- Bread Pudding and Mud Pie. I usually order the trout which is excellent. Yes we will go again and again."
Dined on 2/21/2014
"Salads, rack of lamb, rib-eye, mud pie. The best of the best ! Wish I could eat here every night !"
Dined on 2/13/2014
"Great restaurant. Great food. Great service. Brother's hasn't lost anything from their Mattie's Tavern days."
Dined on 2/11/2014
"Our dinner was nothing short of outstanding. From the sweet potato chipotle soup & house made smoked salmon appetizers to the pork chop and prime rib main courses and walk a mile for house made chocolate and raspberry gelato - a tour de force for the Brothers! Our first visit (we have been to Sides Hardware & Shoes multiple times - yummy) and it will be must go to dining for us. Not to be missed!"
Dined on 2/16/2014
"Use to dine at Mattei's so had to try the Red Barn. The Prime rib was incredible and my wife praised the filet of sole. The Brothers have done a wonderful job and can't wait to go back again."
Dined on 2/15/2014
"First, when we got there we were shocked that the handicapped spaces were so far away from the front door. The waitress was constantly available to make sure we got what we needed.The breads were excellent .The table was was very small and crowded. The appetizer was excellent and tasty. The main course, my wife had the prime rib and she shared the vegetables were excellent but the meat was a little tough and fatty. I am a vegetarian and had the veggie plate. It was adequate nothing special the vegetables were roasted and very bland. We also had desserts they were excellent my wife's lemon pie was the best ever! My dessert was the flour less cake special it was also excellent except the raspberry sorbet was much too strong."
Dined on 2/14/2014
"Food was terrible. No flavor. Prime Rib and Rib Eye steak were tough. Potatoes tasted like instant potatoes. Noise level was unbearable. Very expensive considering the poor quality of the food."
Dined on 2/13/2014
"I had the sole prepared like everywhere else, francaise with fresh green beans and carrots with nothing on them. The mashed potatoes were way too salty so I only took a taste. Nothing special. I can make better at home. Not something I want to say after eating at a restaurant! My husband had the pork chop which he described as comfort food. Not expected at a restaurant that touts itself as being innovative. The only innovative dish was prepared by the pastry chef, a lemon cheesecake that was perfectly balanced with sweetness, tartness and lemon flavor. In an effort to rush us on a Tuesday evening, the waitress delivered the bill while we were still eating our dessert!"
Dined on 2/11/2014
"The two brothers have done it again, reopening at the remodeled Red Barn in Santa Ynez. They've brought that slow cooker they had at Matti's with them and the tenderest prime rib I've ever had. All the food is organic and sourced locally. Having been butchers, the two brothers. butcher, age and cut all their meats on site. The spot on my list for best restaurant in Santa Barbara County has been waiting for them to reopen and threy have claimed it once again."
Dined on 2/1/2014
"Red Barn makes the best Chinese Chicken Salad I have ever eaten -- and terrific, lightly floured calamari! The setting is very simple and comfortable, and the service very friendly. This new eatery in the Santa Ynez Valley is worth a try."
Dined on 2/11/2014
"We have come to know that the brothers are dependable every time. The service is also as good as one could expect."
Dined on 2/10/2014
"We ordered the specials, Filet Mignon Tacos, Cajun Chicken Sandwich and also the Chinese Chicken Salad. Everything was great, fresh and healthy! Service was great as well. I manage a dining room and I was very impressed by the service and the food. I will definately be back!"
Dined on 2/8/2014
"Promptly seated at our reservation time, followed by excellent and caring service by the wait staff. Food prepared per our request and served on a warm plate, excellent flavors. Wonderful homemade desserts including gelato. This was a special evening in celebration of our Anniversary and the evening was most enjoyable. Thank You staff for making this a truly memorable time!"
Dined on 2/4/2014
"Our dinner was amazing, from the moment we walked in the door and were immediately seated, right through the delicious food and right up to the moment the chef came out of the kitchen to ask how our evening had been. We will definitely be back."
Dined on 2/9/2014
"The brothers have created a comfortable, lovely environment for their delicious meals. I love the salmon, huge piece, and the pear salad is great. My husband had the chicken and my brother the steak. All was cooked to perfection. Whenever we have company or an occasion we can think of, we come to the Red Barn. You will not be disappointed."
Dined on 2/5/2014
"We ordered the diver scallops & felt these were the tastiest & most delicious scallops we have ever had. Loved the vegetable/brown rice. Overall, a wonderful dining experience! Can't wait to go back. Wonderful & fast service as well."
Dined on 2/7/2014
"Extremely consistent! Food is always wonderfully presented and so delicious! Service is unparalleled and they do everything in their power to meet any special requests! They made my birthday unforgettable! Thank you!!! Thank you!!! Thank you!!!"
Dined on 2/6/2014
"This family of brothers continues to set an outstanding dining experience."
Dined on 2/4/2014
"Have learned to expect excellence from the Brothers. Wasn't disappointed at all! Terrific food. Great choice of local wines. Service was excellent and very efficient."
Dined on 1/31/2014
"There must be something the brothers don't do well. I simply can't find it. Had veal for the first time in 25 years and theirs was worth the wait."
Dined on 1/30/2014
"First trip to the Red Barn was on a Thursday night and the place was pretty busy, especially the bar. We had reservations and were seated within a minute or two. Joanne, our waitress was excellent. The food was very similar to what the brothers did at Mattei's Tavern. We each had the small prime fillet and it was done perfectly, served with crispy potatoes, green beans and carrots. The wine list was good, but overpriced, especially with a hundred wineries in the area. Bring your own bottle, corkage is $15. They have done a nice job remodeling. It's basically a big room, with a lively bar off to the side that spills into the dining room. Very noisy, but the food and service makes up for that. Will definitely make this a regular stop."
Dined on 1/30/2014
"Every mouthful on our plates was perfect......the steak, the salmon, the potato gratin, the veggies.............can't say enough good things. It was food heaven. And I almost forgot - the mussels for apps. just delicious. Place was packed, so reservations are a must,"
Dined on 1/30/2014
"Delicious and a very special place. Glad the Brothers are back!"
Dined on 1/28/2014
"The Brothers' continue to combine excellent service with outstanding cuisine at the Red Barn. Their menu from Matteis is well-reflected at RBarn, but their are some new additions, as well. For me, I find it hard to resist the rack of lamb with goat cheese mashed potatoes: just a wonderful meal. Service is exceptional. Diane and Terry remain with the team at the new location, and they are two of the most friendly and conscientious servers ever. JC captains the bar and the overall tempo of the restaurant -- super guy and he executes his duties well. Lastly, Jeff & Matt are providing some wonderful food to their multitude of fans. What could be better for a dining experience?? Cheers! RichS"
Dined on 1/25/2014
"we enjoyed our experience. the table was okay especially when I requested a special table for an anniversary. we recognized our server from sides and hardware. Very nice touch for manager and chef to stop by table to inquire. we do like the new look of the "barn""
Dined on 1/24/2014
"Excellent food. Happy to see Trout on the menu. It was always good at Mattie's Will definitely return."
Dined on 1/22/2014
"The food was outstanding as was the service. Great dining experience!"
Dined on 1/21/2014
"This was my third time at the Brothers' new location, and the food and service were very good, as usual. I'll be back again!"
Dined on 1/18/2014
"The Brothers are known for great food, and steaks are supposed to be a specialty, but on this visit we were very disappointed. We started with the tuna tartar, which was a great choice and enough for four. The second course was a salad which could be shared by two. Two diners in our party chose the filet for their dinner, and it was good, cooked to the right temperature, and tender. It is covered in a Stilton cheese and wine sauce which is tasty, but overpowered the flavor of the beef which should be the highlight if cooked and seasoned correctly. The other two diners chose the ribeye and that was a major disappointment. The cut was thin, tough, and flavorless. Worst ribeye steak ever! Not looking forward to returning."
Dined on 1/19/2014
"First time at the new restaurant. Like the remodel and bright and airy feel. Server was pleasant and friendly. Food was tasty."
Dined on 1/19/2014
"We love all the Brother's restaurants! They are consistently Good and the atmosphere is warm & friendly. Highly Recommend their establishments."
Dined on 1/15/2014
"I dined here on a Tuesday night and the restaurant was busy but the service was excellent thanks to our server Joanna. I had the organic salmon served on a bed of vegetable rice which was perfectly cooked and very flavorful. I also tasted the special for the evening, petrale sole, also excellent. Servings were generous. As others have noted, the restaurant is noisy but I had asked for a quiet table when I made the reservation, and I was pleased that we were seated at a table in the back where conversation was easily heard. I will definitely return here for another dinner."
Dined on 1/14/2014
"Although we had reservations, there was about a 20 min wait for our table on a very busy Sunday evening. While waiting, we each had a glass of Syrah in the bar. It was disappointing--especially since there are so many good Syrahs produced in this area. My wife had the small filet mignon and I had the--hang on--charcoal broiled LIVER (the evening special). Both were excellent as is usual at any Brothers restaurant. (We had ordered calamari for a starter but our waitress forgot to put the order in.) In spite of the few minor annoyances, it was a wonderful night out in celebration of our wedding anniversary."
Dined on 1/12/2014
"Glad to see the Brother's restaurant back. Food was delicious, the menu was very similar to what it what it was at Brother's Restaurant at Mattei's Tavern. Everything was perfect and can't wait to go back!"
Dined on 1/4/2014

More reviews ›

Reserve at Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn

Brothers Restaurant at Red Barn Details

Getting there

Related Links

Featured Cities

Popular

OpenTable