Best Italian Restaurants - Long Island / Hamptons

10 Diners' Choice Winners

Restaurant Name Price
The Trattoria
St. James | Italian
$$$
Robert's
Water Mill | Italian
$$$
Il Luogo Ristorante
Rockville Centre | Italian
$$
Piccolo Mondo Restaurant
Huntington | Italian
$$$
Butera's Restaurant of Sayville
Sayville | Italian
$$
Piccolo Restaurant of Huntington
Huntington | Italian
$$$$
Pentimento Restaurant
Stony Brook | Italian
$$$
Passione Della Cucina
Carle Place | Italian
$$
King Umberto Restaurant
Elmont | Italian
$$
18 Bay
Shelter Island | Italian
$$$$
As rated by OpenTable diners Learn More »