Best Overall Restaurants - Long Island / Hamptons

10 Diners' Choice Winners

Restaurant Name Price
Thai House
Smithtown | Thai
$$
The Trattoria
St. James | Italian
$$$
The North Fork Table & Inn
North Fork | Contemporary American
$$$$
King Umberto Restaurant
Elmont | Italian
$$
Robert's
Water Mill | Italian
$$$
Galleria Ristorante - Westbury
Westbury | Italian
$$$
Rialto Restaurant
Carle Place | Continental
$$$
Tellers: An American Chophouse
Islip | Steak
$$$$
Gemelli's Restaurant
Babylon | Italian
$$
Starr Boggs
Hamptons | Contemporary American
$$$$
As rated by OpenTable diners Learn More »