Baxters American GrilleBirthday nosh - table for two...This was a little celebration for the two of us for a Birthday. Baxter's honored our request for an intimate table in the back, which was wonderful, but the only complaint was the noise spill over from the bar. I love their bar when I'm in it, but from a dining perspective, not so much. The service was great and the food was delicious, as always. If it weren't for the noise, it would have been a perfect evening...5/11/2013 12:00:00 AMUnexpected DelightHad to drive over from Peoria to pick up someone from Bloomington airport coming in on a late flight. Thought we'd strike out when it came to finding a good place open late. Baxter's was an unexpected delight. Our waiter was professional but unobtrusive. Chorizo stuffed mushrooms and quesadillas were tasty appetizers. The planked salmon was a great entree choice. Bar is noisy, but dining room is quiet enough for a pleasant conversation. Good selection of not-so-ordinary beer on tap. Will plan to return should the occasion arise.5/2/2013 12:00:00 AMA step above...A great place for a steak or seafood. The Baxter's salad is delicious and so is the gooey butter cake for dessert. Definitely a step above most chain restaurants.4/27/2013 12:00:00 AMLoved the veal chopsThis was our second visit to Baxters. I love to cook so I ususally order something I don't often make myself. This time my husband and I had the veal chop medium rare with mushroom gravy and garlic mashed potatoes...very delicious, thick and juicy. I love chardonnay and there were four to select from. Our booth had both bench and chairs and felt very private. Our friends had the prime rib and said it also was very good. I especially liked the tasty spinach salad which was not soggy and had a lot of crunchy bacon. We will go back again.4/19/2013 12:00:00 AMMy husband and I went to dinnerMy husband and I went to dinner here on a Saturday night for my birthday and it was the perfect splurge. They have sizable wine and cocktail lists. Good variation in menu items, and wide variation in menu prices. Steak or seafood dishes run about $25. I'd recommend the scallops 3 ways to any seafood lovers - unique and flavorful! Service was excellent. Our server was attentive, friendly, and knew the menu well. Food courses came out at a great pace. Saturday nights are packed and loud. I recommend reservations. There was a band in the bar area that made it too loud for my taste. But other than that the night was perfect!4/13/2013 12:00:00 AMMediocre food, trendy atmosphereStopped at Baxters during a business trip to Bloomington. Food was only o.k., nothing really special or outstanding. Our waiter was excellent and very attentive. Time to receive our food was SLOW SLOW SLOW. After ordering it took 30 minutes to get our appetizer, 40 minutes to get our side salads and an hour and 20 minutes to get our entrees. Since we were not in any rush this was not a huge issue for us but a 2 hour dinner for 2 people is ridiculous!4/3/2013 12:00:00 AMwe love this in our neighborhood.we love this in our neighborhood. the food is outstanding and it is so quiet you are able to sit and talk a your table. much different than the other restaurants in the area. I just hope Baxter's stays above the young drinking and noisy crowd to preserve what it offers3/23/2013 12:00:00 AMWe continue to enjoy our visitsWe continue to enjoy our visits to Baxters and have become "regulars" there.3/14/2013 12:00:00 AM